Lee Cataluna: Fireworks Are Not Cultural. They're Insanity
We need our political leaders — looking at you, Josh Green, and you, Rick Blangiardi — to do what regular citizens have no power to stop.
By Lee Cataluna
January 19, 2025 · 5 min read
About the Author
We need our political leaders — looking at you, Josh Green, and you, Rick Blangiardi — to do what regular citizens have no power to stop.
When Hawaiʻi leaders talk about trying to stop the scourge of illegal fireworks, they seem almost apologetic about having to be the mean parent. Like, “Aww, I know, buddy. You were having so much fun, weren’t you? But I really don’t want you to get hurt, okay?”
I’m not sure they’re reading the room correctly.
People are completely sick and tired of the insanity. They have been for years. They roll their eyes at the promises to stop illegal fireworks. They assume everyone is getting paid off and nothing will ever happen.
Be the hammer, Gov. Josh Green.
You’re the plain-speaking mayor, Rick Blangiardi.
Do what needs to be done. Come down hard with no apologies. It’s not about finding a compromise that lets everybody have a little of what they want. It’s about stopping the war-like violence in our neighborhoods.
There is this false narrative that all Hawaiʻi people dearly looooooove fireworks, and that even those who aren’t blowing up the sky every Dec. 31 are tolerant of the illegal explosives.
It has become an unchallenged excuse that protects inaction.
Obviously, some people love the thrill of setting off explosions outside their carports.
Clearly many people love the money to be made by importing and selling black market pyrotechnics. Others enjoy watching the mayhem in the night skies from a safe distance, if there is such a thing as a safe distance anywhere on Oʻahu on the night of Dec. 31.
But not everyone loves fireworks. The amount of anger that rises up every time we go through another New Year’s night of mayhem seems to represent a significant part of the population. Many people hate the chaos and are furious at the impunity with which bigger and more dangerous incendiary devices are employed by amateur arsonists every year. People are not merely irritated, not aggrieved, not annoyed or inconvenienced. Furious.
It’s also wrong to assert that Hawaiʻi residents who don’t set off illegal fireworks themselves nevertheless “tolerate” them. To tolerate something means to not interfere with something even though one may not like it.
Hawaiʻi doesn’t so much tolerate the mayhem as endure it with a kind of learned helplessness.
This, sadly, is a big part of what it takes to live on an overcrowded island. One must learn to be helpless to live with Hawaiʻi’s ever-growing traffic problems, to keep paying the high cost of basic groceries, to weave past homeless people lurching around downtown screaming at the sky, to live with all these terrible things we know we cannot change.
To be fair, in the joint press conference in the hours after the New Year’s fireworks disaster, both the governor and the mayor said things have got to change.
They said it forcefully. Both were brimming with emotion.
And then they kind of took it back by saying that they understand that fireworks are traditional and cultural, like that somehow makes them holy and unquestionable. Again, a ridiculous idea.
A couple of strings of firecrackers hanging from the pole of a mango picker is traditional and cultural. What currently goes down during New Year’s is inexcusable.
Also inexcusable is the idea that somehow we as civilian nobodies can enact change by policing our neighbors ourselves.
It is impossible for a regular citizen — a homebody kupuna or a busy parent or a 20-something renter — to feel like they have any power over what mischief their neighbor is up to. The longer you’ve lived in the neighborhood, the harder it is to feel like you can tattle on your neighbor’s antics or go knock on their door and ask them to please play safe. We know how this goes. Those poor people out on Waiʻanae Valley Road had been asking for help with their unruly neighbor and his “Silva Dome” for years before he snapped and came at them with a bulldozer and a gun. They still had to stop him themselves. When the police finally did something, they arrested the hero who brought an end to the murderous rampage. We know how this goes.
What a glorious achievement it would be for Gov. Green and Mayor Blangiardi to be able to say that they were the ones who brought peace and safety to the island on New Year’s Eve. Those two leaders, both with their own brand of swagger and ambition, should take up the challenge to do the supposedly unpopular thing and come down hard on this nonsense.
Of course, much of this will be in the hands of the Legislature, those Rix-wearing wonks, many of whom were elected by only 1,000 votes or so, who live in fear of upsetting anybody in their district or on their donor list.
The state attorney general’s proposal sounds promising, but it remains to be seen if the Legislature will find the guts to do what should have been done long ago. And there aren’t many hammers or plain-speakers in that assembly.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
ĚěĂŔĘÓƵ is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Lee Cataluna is a columnist for Civil Beat. You can reach her by email at lcataluna@civilbeat.org
Latest Comments (0)
The people that set off fireworks are generally the people who don't abide by laws. Especially the big illegal fireworks, which are also associated with drug and alcohol use as well as guns and other items of violence.
Scotty_Poppins · 2 hours ago
Thank you for your column, Lee. We don’t see too many of your columns these days, but when we do, I really resonate with them. I agree with everything you said. It’s ridiculous and complete insanity that our elected leaders have allowed these NYE illegal fireworks to go off year after year in spite of severe injuries to people which required transport to the mainland for treatment. The people shipped to AZ are still in ICU. I’d love for Civil Beat to research the cost breakdown of having to send these people to AZ for treatment and who exactly is paying for it. Is it the individuals’ private insurance or is it our tax dollars? I too am disappointed in the governor and the mayor for allowing this year after year and turning a blind eye. We elected you to govern, not to turn a blind eye. And where is Steve Alm in all of this. He was the one who said he was going to be tough on crime. So far I haven’t seen that. Please do your jobs and stop the insanity. It’s completely out of hand and ridiculous.
MauiAloha · 3 hours ago
Cultural Tradition: Growing up the '60s on the Big Island, my fondest childhood memory was New Years eve, where us kids would line up on a rocky cliff next to my grandparents' house and toss over lighted Duck Brand and Camel Brand firecrackers and try to get them to explode in the air, while the grownups were back in the house feasting, drinking and talking story. I had a few explode in my fingers but left nothing more than a tingling sensation. At midnight we would fire off small bottle rockets, roman candles and a few strings of ducks without setting their coffee farm while the grownups looked out from the windows above us. Insanity: After graduating college, spent six as an army engineer officer and learned about real explosives, e.g. C4, TNT, WP, etc. whose derivatives seem to be used in the current recreational and very lethal fireworks.
maruywa · 5 hours ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.