ÌìÃÀÊÓƵ

In the aftermath of the Aug. 8, 2023, fires, I feared that developer and construction interests would seize the devastation as an opportunity to pursue projects that serve their own financial gains at the expense of the community. Regrettably, these fears are being realized as familiar union and developer voices advocate for the relocation of Kamehameha III School to Kuia.

This proposal, however, raises serious concerns that must not be overlooked. From water shortages and safety risks to infrastructure readiness and community well-being, relocating the school to Kuia is far from a practical solution.

A Looming Water Crisis

One of the most pressing issues is water supply. Before the fires, Lahaina was already at full capacity, struggling to meet the water needs of its residents.

The post-fire landscape has only exacerbated this challenge, with many displaced homeowners planning to rebuild and add additional dwelling units to their properties. How can the county possibly support new developments in Kuia when it has yet to address longstanding projects like Pulelehua, Kaanapali 2020, Puukolii Village, and DHHL developments in Leialii and Honokowai?

Adding more pressure to an already strained system could have far-reaching consequences, including potentially jeopardizing the restoration of Mokuhinia Pond, an ecologically and culturally significant site that relies on groundwater resources.

Moreover, relocating to Kuia would require extensive and time-consuming steps such as completing an environmental impact statement, zoning changes, securing water sources, and making amendments to district boundaries and community plans. Each of these steps presents its own set of challenges that could delay the project further and drain public resources.

Who Does This Really Serve?

After attending a community meeting with Kamehameha Schools, it became clear that the push to build in Kuia is motivated by a desire to leverage government funding for infrastructure — an example of disaster capitalism at its finest, where profit is placed above community needs.

This kind of opportunism must be called out, especially when it puts our keiki at risk.

The Needs Of The Community

An estimated 80% of Kamehameha III School’s student body lives in upper West Maui. Relocating the school to Kuia, a considerable distance from where most families reside, would create logistical difficulties and add stress to students and parents alike.

The location of Pulelehua, already serving as the temporary site, is a far more suitable option. It is ideally situated to serve the needs of the majority of the student body, reducing travel times and keeping the school integrated within the community it serves.

Fire Hazards Cannot Be Ignored

One of the most glaring issues with placing the school in Kuia is the increased fire risk. The devastating events of Aug. 8 underscored how susceptible this area is to wildfires, fueled by the fierce Kauaula winds. Even with decades of land management and strategic agricultural practices, the inherent dryness of Kuia means that the risk of fire cannot be entirely mitigated.

Placing a school in such an environment would be a gamble with the safety of students, teachers, and staff — one that should not be taken.

Infrastructure Readiness, Long-term Practicality

Unlike Kuia, Pulelehua already has the infrastructure to support a permanent school. Leveraging this pre-existing infrastructure not only makes sense from a financial perspective but also accelerates the transition to a stable, long-term learning environment.

Starting from scratch in Kuia would lead to significant delays and inflate public spending, diverting resources that could be better used to support recovery efforts and community programs.

Traffic And Accessibility

Before the fires, traffic congestion along Lahainaluna Road and the Lahaina Bypass was a significant issue. Adding a school at Kuia would only worsen the problem, leading to more delays for families and potentially impacting emergency response times.

Pulelehua’s strategic location minimizes these risks and ensures better accessibility for the families of upper West Maui.

Respecting Community, Cultural Values

Finally, placing Kamehameha III School in Kuia risks disrespecting the wishes of the community and undermining long-term cultural and environmental priorities. The community has already voiced its support for sustainable and sensible solutions that align with the region’s needs.

Pulelehua is that solution — it meets the community’s needs, protects precious water resources, and preserves the integrity of West Maui’s environmental and cultural landscape.

Conclusion

The proposal to relocate Kamehameha III School to Kuia raises more questions than it answers. From water shortages and fire risks to logistical challenges and infrastructure costs, it is clear that the plan is not in the best interest of the community.

This is not just about building a school; it’s about making a decision that prioritizes the safety, well-being, and future of our keiki and families.

I urge Mayor Richard Bissen to reconsider and support the relocation of Kamehameha III School to Pulelehua — a choice that aligns with the values, needs, and sustainability of our West Maui community.