Neal Milner: The Bittersweet Evolution Of A Long-Distance Grandparent
The child who was my granddaughter has disappeared, but there are rewards in adjusting to the adolescent one.
By Neal Milner
June 20, 2024 · 7 min read
About the Author
The child who was my granddaughter has disappeared, but there are rewards in adjusting to the adolescent one.
A few weeks ago, my wife Joy and I had a surprisingly hard visit with our children and granddaughter in Portland.
Grandparents are not supposed to say that.
Well, it happened, and for a very important reason. Things have changed. My granddaughter Vivienne is not the same kid anymore. She鈥檚 now twelve, an adolescent.
If you think this is the beginning of a sad, poor-grandpa story, it isn鈥檛.
Frolicky Grandpa
At first, being a grandparent is like being in a Disney movie. It鈥檚 a family frolic.
For long-distant grandparents like us a visit was The Really Big Frolic.
In the flesh. Velvet-rope box seats.聽All that touching, holding, singing, and listening to the many things a little kid granddaughter wants to tell you about herself and her world.聽
鈥淟ook, grandma, look grandpa. See what I can do!鈥 All in all, it鈥檚 lovely and smooth sailing with the grandchild at center stage, the only star.
Viv wanted to be the center of attention any chance she got. She began to make instructional videos starring herself and talked on them like a YouTube influencer: 鈥淗i guys. Be sure to..鈥
The only skill set we grandparents needed came from :
A smile a perfect gift for me
as wide as a mile.
To make me happy as can be
Smile, smile, smile, smile, smile!
Then along comes adolescence: Yo, Pinky Pie. Aloha and good-bye.
Exit Frolicky Grandpa
During our recent visit, it became clear that we鈥檇 become more incidental to Viv鈥檚 life. She liked spending time alone in her room and reading on her own. She was uninterested, sometimes highly annoyed, at being the center of attention.
Viv didn鈥檛 want to displease us, but she certainly wasn鈥檛 all that concerned with pleasing us either.
So, during that three-week visit, Joy and I spent a lot of time worrying and wondering. It鈥檚 uncanny how closely this sadness matched the description on .
We worried that the 鈥済randchild won’t know you, or you them. You’re failing somehow, as if you should be doing more but don’t know what [and] running out of ideas and not finding any good ones.鈥
Topped off by this coup de grace on the already wounded ancient bull elk: 鈥済rief for the loss of relationships … overwhelmed at the prospect of the journey ahead.鈥
鈥淕rief for the loss and overwhelmed by the journey ahead鈥 sounds like a deathbed scene. In a way, it is.
Well, you can grieve, or you can arise from the dead by adapting.
The first part of this journey is to see that adaption as a challenge. And you should see that older people are adept at meeting even one as emotionally disorienting as how you relate to a child who is that child no more.
Developing a new way of relating to a person you love is not exactly like trying a senior center ceramics class or walking onto the pickle ball court for the first time.
Call this capacity brain power. (The experts鈥 term is 鈥渆xecutive function.鈥) Consider the relationship between emerging adolescents and their grandparents as the interaction of two brains, adolescent and aged.
The arc of the adolescent brain is rapid development. But along the way there are huge fits, starts, and bumps in the road. Beginning at age 10, the adolescent brain begins a wild ride continuing for roughly another ten years.
Getting rid of the old and bringing in the new can seem pretty stressful and out of control. So, at 12, the brain is taking gigantic, sometimes erratic, and hard-to-understand leaps. Extremely intelligent and mature one minute, very vulnerable the next.
The overall arc of old person鈥檚 brain is not development but decline. Of course it is. But this downward slope is not as steep or as sad as you might think.
鈥淭here is growing evidence,鈥 the , 鈥渢hat the [aged] brain maintains the ability to change and adapt so that people can manage new challenges and tasks as they age.鈥
Developing a new sort of relationship with Viv is one of those adaptable tasks. Rather than distant child and grieving grandpa, I see my new relationship with her as one between a young woman who on some days functions like an adult while on others is vulnerable and an old person who still has the experience and brain power to deal with this.
What can I do to make this adaptation work? I don鈥檛 know yet. Developing a new way of relating to a person you love is not exactly like trying a senior center ceramics class or walking onto the pickle ball court for the first time.
Even though Joy and I were mainly mired in the poor-grandparents phase, we stumbled into a few adjustments.
The Beginnings of a Work in Progress: Three Portland Visit Vignettes
My son asked me to take Viv to her dance class less than one-and-a-half miles away.
Viv didn鈥檛 argue but seemed a little skeptical that I could actually pull this project off. She told me the exact time we had to leave and assumed I needed directions even though I had been there before and have been driving in Portland since the early 90鈥檚. She told me when to change lanes and where to make the final turn.
Not exactly grandpa sharing his mana鈥檕 or holding granddaughter鈥檚 hand as they stroll to the slides and swings, but I鈥檒l take it. It made me laugh.
One evening, as we sat in the living room, my son mentioned that Vivienne had written a poem in a 15-minute free writing session of her sixth-grade creative writing class. He asked her to read it. Viv agreed, though she certainly did not seem excited.
Now, she is a very smart person who has real writing talents. Even so, this poem blew me away.
It was a beautifully written and extraordinarily expressed poem about emotions. I told her how good I thought it was and that I doubted that in that short a time I could string that many words together, much less something of that quality.
She seemed pleased at the compliment but not infant-big-smile-for-grandma-and-grandpa pleased. We did not applaud. I did not hug her. No one suggested making a video, which in my frolicky grandpa days I would have shared with many, many people.
The last week we were there Vivienne asked me if on the weekend I would take her to a diner she liked. I was so delighted.
Joy said she would go too, which made me secretly disappointed because I was hoping it would just be grandpa and the little Brooklyn preschooler I used to know.
The breakfast was very comfortable and uneventful. No probing, no trying to force conversation.
The visit had already reminded Joy and me that making conversation or giving unsolicited advice is a grandparent idea. 鈥淗ow鈥檚 school?鈥 or 鈥淲hat are you going to do with the rest of your day?鈥 is as much a non-starter as it was when your children were that age.
Viv helped Joy when she had trouble using the machine to pay the bill.
A few days later Joy and I left for the airport. It was 5:30 a.m. Viv was still sleeping. We did not wake her to say good-bye.
It made me wistful, but it felt right.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
The Sunshine Blog: Les Kondo Wants To Set The Record Straight
By The Sunshine Editorial Board · June 21, 2024 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Neal Milner is a former political science professor at the University of Hawai驶i where he taught for 40 years. He is a political analyst for KITV and is a regular contributor to Hawaii Public Radio's His most recent book is Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Latest Comments (0)
Sometimes I find Neal脢禄s commentary to be bordering on hubris. But he occasionally shares his vulnerability like this piece, which strikes a good balance.
eolamauno · 6 months ago
There's no doubt that your granddaughter will love you, forever and a day. How could she not?
cavan8 · 6 months ago
Mahalo for sharing, Professor Milner. Be proud that your granddaughter Viv inherited your instructional skills and writing talent! Maybe she will follow in your footsteps as contributing writer (not nepo baby!) to Civil Beat? By spending time alone reading in her room, she is relating to other writers and expanding her world view芒聙娄 so understandable that she no longer seeks to be the center of attention. This alone time supports creative expression.According to Erikson芒聙聶s theory of psychosocial development, adolescence is time for identity exploration and old age is time for retrospection/transcendence. These stages appear complementary, which make for rich intergenerational interactions.My grandparents (who were short-distance as they lived downstairs in our single-family residence) experienced some "distancing" from me (and my siblings) during our free-range adolescence, but food always brought us together芒聙娄 just like Viv asking you to take her to breakfast diner. Aloha kaukau time!
introvert · 6 months ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.