Catherine Toth Fox: Turtle Bay's New Owners Should Move Forward With The Community
The coastline may see two more hotels聽and decidedly more impact on the neighborhood.
June 21, 2024 · 5 min read
About the Author
The coastline may see two more hotels聽and decidedly more impact on the neighborhood.
Staycations weren鈥檛 really a thing when I was a kid. But I do have memories of staying at Turtle Bay Hilton, what the now-luxe resort was called in the 鈥80s.
Rooms back then started at $120 (according to a Los Angeles Times story I found from 1988), which was still a splurge for my middle-class family. But it was attainable, and we loved playing in the pool and riding big-wheeled water tricycles in Kuilima Cove.
Today, 36 years later, rooms start at $979 a night 鈥 this was the lowest rate I was quoted for this weekend 鈥 with upgrade options for better views and nearly $230 in taxes and fees (including a $58.99 resort service fee). It鈥檚 definitely more than a splurge now.
In May, Maryland-based Host Hotels & Resorts, which owns almost 80 hotels, to acquire the 450-room resort and nearby land for $725 million from Blackstone Real Estate. The deal is expected to close in late July, at which time it will transition management to Marriott and rebrand as a Ritz-Carlton.
The deal includes a 49-acre parcel 鈥渆ntitled for development,鈥 the company said in a news release.
In a separate deal, the Utah-based developer Arete Collective is buying 65 acres of land at Turtle Bay from Blackstone for another $43 million.
It doesn鈥檛 take a real estate genius to see the potential for big changes to the neighborhood.
Right now there are only two hotels on the coastline: Turtle Bay Resort and the more affordable Courtyard by Marriot in Laie. A luxury brand like the Ritz-Carlton could mean higher hotel rates that aren鈥檛 attainable for the everyday traveler (or local family).
But this purchase could mean more development along this rugged coastline.
It brings back different memories: In 2006 protesters fought the proposed expansion of Turtle Bay Resort, arguing that the developer, Kuilima Resort Co., needed to update its environmental impact statement that was 25 years old.
Opponents argued that in the 25 years since the original EIS was approved, the area had changed. Changes to traffic patterns, nesting of endangered species such Hawaiian monk seals and green sea turtles, possibly the discovery of iwi (ancestral bones).
At the time, protesters said they didn鈥檛 need any more hotels. In April 2010 the Hawai Supreme Court ruled in their favor, setting the precedent that landowners can be required to get new approvals if the surrounding area has changed.
It was a victory for opponents. But here we are, 24 years later, and the coastline may see two more hotels 鈥斅燼nd decidedly more impact on the neighborhood.
But there has been progress, too.
For example, in 2016 the Trust for Public Land, along with many partners including the North Shore Community Land Trust, secured the protection of 468 acres of productive farmland mauka along Kamehameha Highway.
The land, which is owned by Turtle Bay Resort and managed by Honolulu-based natural resource conservation company Pono Pacific, continues to be farmed.
The hotel鈥檚 Kuilima Farm grows vegetables, herbs, fruits and edible flowers for its restaurants, and another 11 private farmers 鈥 the ones who had been here farming prior to 2016 鈥 still operate, supplying the hotel with produce, too. There are also 34 garden plots for North Shore residents who want to grow their own food.
These 468 acres 鈥 along with another 628 along the coastline 鈥 are now under a conservation easement. Meaning it can鈥檛 be altered and housing can鈥檛 be built, even if the resort sells it. Which it did this year.
According to TPL鈥檚 Hawaii director, Lea Hong, these 1,200 acres of North Shore land are permanently protected. That鈥檚 a huge win for the community.
But there have also been other wins.
Blackstone bought the 1,180-acre oceanfront hotel in 2018 for $332 million and spent millions of dollars transforming the property. The result goes far beyond the upgraded guest rooms and suites.
The lobby features large-scale works of art by Hawaii-based artists including Nick Kuchar and Native Hawaiian printmaker Abigail Romanchak.
The hotel鈥檚 restaurants, in particular Alaia, source locally, including from the hotel鈥檚 own farm less than a mile away. And the hotel hosts a variety of cultural experiences, from workshops that teach you how to weave coconut fronds or string a simple lei to nighttime stargazing to learn about the ancient art of Hawaiian navigation. The hotel offers bird-watching tours, horsemanship classes and guided night snorkeling.
Not to mention Turtle Bay, like the other hotel and various restaurants and attractions in the area, employ a lot of North Shore residents.
And, as of now, the hotel allows the general public to walk its grounds and park in its lot to access the beaches.
According to the hotel, there are no immediate changes expected to the guest experience, including cultural activities. And no additional construction is planned at this time. Hotel rates, though, are determined by market conditions and could go up with the Ritz-Carlton brand. That鈥檚 TBD.
So we鈥檒l have to wait and see what happens. Let驶s just hope the new owners learn from the past and move forward as part of the community.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Beth Fukumoto: How Hawaii Democrats And Republicans Can Affect The Presidential Election
By Beth Fukumoto · June 23, 2024 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Born and raised on Oahu, Catherine Toth Fox is an editor, writer, children鈥檚 book author, blogger and former journalism instructor. She is currently the editor at large for Hawaii Magazine and lives in Honolulu with her husband, son and two dogs. You can follow her on Instagram @catherinetothfox. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Latest Comments (0)
Lets see if local access to the property and beach will not be affected.
roger808808 · 6 months ago
Seeing how the Ritz Carlton in Waikiki was able to skirt development guidelines and receive special waivers from the City to build two monster towers that completely blocked the ocean view of an existing Four Paddle condo that was there for over 40 years, it will be interesting to see what special treatment the Ritz will receive in developing the Turtle Bay area.
Mnemosyne · 6 months ago
I think it important to note that the leadership for the Owners in 2013 prepared and processed a complete Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement that was approved amd proposed a significant reduction in total units from 3,500 to 1,875 additional to be developed. Key stakeholders communicated to the leadership team they wanted to reduce further the fully entitled 3,500 resort hotel units. The Owners work with the State, County. TFP, NSCLT and others to conserve 663 of 845 acres and reduce total new units to be develop to 725 Units. Including more and improved access to the coastline and conservation lands. This was a creative, fair and reasonable arrangement from a for profit developer to partner with the community for balanced and responsible development plan. Let芒聙聶s all live with honor and Aloha.
LocalBoy · 6 months ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.