Access to water is still in flux, but the Maui modular home housing project now has county approval to open 16 of 88 units.

Lahaina resident Michele Fernandez has spent the last several months living with her family in an enclosed carport in Central Maui, courtesy of church friends.

Late Friday afternoon, Fernandez learned that she, her husband and two sons, ages 18 and 22, will be able to move into a pair of modular homes at Ohana Hope Village in Kahului on Wednesday.

After months of delay, the village 鈥 a collection of 88 modular homes that Family Life Center erected near the airport 鈥 finally received a much-needed permit from the Maui Department of Public Works.

鈥淚鈥檓 in shock,鈥 Fernandez said.

Ohana Hope Village is photographed Wednesday, Feb. 21, 2024, in Kahului. The village will house Lahaina residents displaced by the Aug. 8 fire. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)
Ohana Hope Village is set to begin moving in displaced fire survivor families next week to occupy 16 of 88 modular housing units. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)

Fernandez had trouble wrapping her head around the reality she might actually be getting a home after so many false starts with Ohana Hope Village, a donation-funded housing project designed to house survivors of the Aug. 8 wildfire that killed 101 people and left some 13,000 displaced.

鈥淭hey were planning on opening it in November. Then it was February. Then it was April 4,鈥 Fernandez said.

April 4 was her birthday and things looked fairly certain at that point, she said. The family鈥檚 bags were packed and Fernandez looked forward to celebrating by moving into her new, temporary home. But it wasn鈥檛 to be.

Family Life Center issued a press release last month saying Ohana Hope Village鈥檚 doors were open and the housing project was accepting the first families, but the organization had to retract it. Ohana Hope Village had been bogged down for months by problems with permitting and water issues and April was no different.

The project’s chief operating officer, Ashley Kelly, said in an interview this week that access to a water line controlled by the Alexander & Baldwin real estate company never came through as expected. The privately controlled line was expected to provide temporary water until the village could tap into a nearby county water main.

A crucial building permit from Maui County also was lacking. That finally came through late Friday afternoon.

Dr. Ashley Kelly is photographed at Ohana Hope Village Wednesday, Feb. 21, 2024, in Kahului. The village will house Lahaina residents displaced by the Aug. 8 fire. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)
Ashley Kelly said she is elated to have received a county permit on Friday that will allow her to open up 16 of 88 modular housing units in Kahului to survivors of the Aug. 8 wildfires that killed at least 101 people in Lahaina. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)

By the time she issued the news release, Kelly had already received more than 800 applications representing over 2,000 people who wanted to move in.

Still, after months of frustrating delays, Kelly found two words to describe her emotions on Friday after Department of Public Works Director Jordan Molina issued a permit that allows 16 units, serviced by a water holding tank, to accept families.

鈥淚鈥檓 elated,鈥 she said.

David Sellers, the Maui architect who volunteered his time to design Ohana Hope Village, said he felt grateful the permit finally came through. But he never expected it to take so long.

鈥淲e just assumed after the fire that people would come together,鈥 he said.

Continest CEO North America Yan Pronin, from left, Hawaii Off-Grid Architect & Engineering principal David Sellers and Family Life Center COO Dr. Ashley Kelly stand outside of  structures for emergency housing Monday, Aug. 21, 2023, in Kahului. The Biden are touring areas of Maui affected by wildfires. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2023)
From left, Continest CEO North America Yan Pronin, Hawaii Off Grid principal David Sellers and Family Life Center Chief Operating Officer Ashley Kelly stand outside some of Continest’s modular housing units in August, less than two weeks after wildfires destroyed much of Lahaina and parts of Upcountry. The units were intended to house fire survivors starting in November but delays over water access and permitting prevented families from moving in. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2023)

It wasn’t for lack of trying, according to the county.

DPW director Molina provided a statement saying the long-delayed permit was held up because Ohana Hope Village lacked infrastructure and access routes to adequately serve the project.

鈥淭his has significantly complicated the approval process, as it necessitates thorough assessments and extensive planning to ensure that the infrastructure meets the needs of the project and adheres to regulatory requirements,鈥 Molina wrote.

Jordan Molina directs Maui County’s Department of Public Works. (Maui County)

The county must follow health and safety standards, he said.

鈥淲hile we acknowledge the concerns surrounding the delays in permit approval, we want to assure the public that every decision made is guided by our unwavering commitment to safeguarding the well-being of all individuals who will be living in these dwelling units,鈥 Molina said.

An Alexander & Baldwin spokeswoman said on Saturday that the company had not heard from Family Life Center since mid-March when it offered to help with a temporary water solution. The company has an 18-inch water line that runs under the land where Ohana Hope Village sits and connects with Maui Business Park.

“Our understanding is they would next pursue the necessary regulatory approvals to ensure that both the permanent and short-term water solution would be done safely,” A&B spokesperson Andrea Galvin said in a statement. “Because this effort involves access to water many people rely on for drinking and fire protection, we await confirmation of critical government, health and safety approvals.” 

Ohana Hope Village is built on 10 acres owned by King鈥檚 Cathedral. The church leases the property to Family Life Center, a nonprofit homeless service provider, for $1 a year. The village intends to provide free housing, case management and other services for up to 350 fire survivors for three to five years.

In February, after months of back and forth between Family Life Center, its pro-bono architect and engineer and A&B, it looked like a solution was at hand and that the modular units could tap into the real estate company’s water line, Kelly said.

But things didn鈥檛 go as smoothly as hoped.

Access to water challenged Ohana Hope Village Wednesday, Feb. 21, 2024, in Kahului. The village will house Lahaina residents displaced by the Aug. 8 fire. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)
Access to water delayed the opening of Ohana Hope Village. Underneath the property runs a private water line controlled by real estate company Alexander & Baldwin. The company has said it’s trying to help Family Life Center find a permanent water source before allowing it to tap into its line tempoarily. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)

Galvin said in late February that A&B was supporting Family Life Center as it worked with the county to secure a permanent water source.

But months went by without progress.

On Friday, Kimo Landgraf, Maui County deputy water director, said his department has granted Ohana Hope Village approval to horizontally drill underneath a highway to tap into an existing county water main outside Zippy鈥檚 Kahului restaurant.

Kimo Landgraf is deputy director of Maui County Department of Water Supply. (Maui County)

Once that happens, the village will have an approved, permanent water source, he said.

A donor has stepped up to provide the estimated $500,000 to $750,000 to cover costs of drilling and pipe laying to access county water, Sellers said.

鈥淭hings don鈥檛 happen fast in Hawaii,鈥 he said.

If Maui is to ever solve its housing crisis, Sellers added, 鈥渨e have to move faster.”

For Fernandez, moving into Ohana Hope Village next week will bring her family some much-needed peace, she said.

It’ll also bring displaced West Maui families together in one spot. Even though it may be far from jobs in Kaanapali and elsewhere in West Maui, it’s a place to live and start building a future after so much loss.

“It鈥檚 all Lahaina people and we鈥檒l all have something in common. We鈥檒l have hope,” Fernandez said.

Civil Beat鈥檚 coverage of Maui County is supported in part by a grant from the Nuestro Futuro Foundation.

Support Independent, Unbiased News

Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.

 

About the Author