Kealii Lopez is the state director of AARP Hawaii, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to empowering Americans 50 and older to choose how they live as they age. Her career spans more than three decades and includes executive and leadership positions in government, nonprofit and business organizations.
Sterling Higa serves as executive director of Housing Hawaii’s Future, a movement creating opportunities for Hawaii’s next generation by ending the workforce housing shortage. He lives in Haiku with his wife and four children.
It provides options that are lacking for young professionals, families and kupuna.
When Hawaii families talk, older and younger generations often have different perspectives. But they unfortunately agree on one topic: despair and desperation about finding decent, affordable housing in Hawaii.
Hawaii’s housing shortage is splitting families — younger residents are leaving the islands because they can’t afford to buy or rent homes and kupuna are finding it harder to age in place in communities where they feel at home.
We can blame our lack of options on outdated planning and permitting systems, which favor either sprawling, low-density single-detached houses or tall high-rises.
Under the status quo, one of the best options for young families and downsizing seniors — backyard accessory dwelling units, small neighborhood duplexes, or modest fourplexes, are either too difficult to get permitted or banned outright. This “missing middle housing” is compatible with single-family homes and affordable, so it is baffling that regulations ban these vital housing options.
With Hawaii’s median home price among the highest in the nation and limited land on which to build new housing, we need diverse and affordable housing options.
For Future Generations
Missing middle housing provides options that are lacking for young professionals, families, and kupuna. Duplexes, triplexes, townhomes and accessory dwelling units offer a middle ground between single-family homes and large apartment buildings. But to build them, we need to allow and permit them.
At Housing Hawaii’s Future, advocating for missing middle housing is an important step in ensuring that future generations can call Hawaii home. As long as housing costs continue to outpace income, young people will be priced out of the communities they grew up in.
Housing like triplexes and townhomes allow our diverse and often multi-generational families to live close to each other and give all residents more pathways to affordable homeownership and rentals. Allowing homeowners to build additional housing helps them cover the costs of their mortgages while creating much needed rental stock.
Housing options like accessory dwelling units and small complexes can accommodate the changing needs of kupuna who may want to downsize from a larger home but still remain in the neighborhoods they know and feel comfortable in. It would allow kupuna to build multigenerational homes, so they can live with their children and grandchildren. It would also allow them to build a unit for a caregiver.
This legislative session, our legislators can pass “Missing Middle Housing” legislation, and its Senate companion . The bills allow smaller, more affordable homes in our neighborhoods where they fit in, preserving all existing county regulations on building size and infrastructure capacity.
The bill is limited to the urban land use district, reducing the pressure to sprawl into agricultural and conservation land. As Daniel Orodenker, the head of the Land Use Commission, said in his supportive testimony, these bills will “protect agricultural lands by removing some of the development pressures on those areas.”
By allowing homes on smaller plots of land and allowing several homes to a lot, SB 3202 and HB 1630 lower the cost of buying a home in our neighborhoods and empower multiple generations to remain together, keeping our local families in Hawaii.
This affordable housing solution doesn’t require hundreds of millions of dollars in taxpayer subsidies. Families can create their own affordable housing with their own money. But government has to get out of the way and allow it to happen.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many
topics of
community interest. It’s kind of
a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or
interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800
words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia
formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org. The opinions and
information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
Kealii Lopez is the state director of AARP Hawaii, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to empowering Americans 50 and older to choose how they live as they age. Her career spans more than three decades and includes executive and leadership positions in government, nonprofit and business organizations.
Sterling Higa serves as executive director of Housing Hawaii’s Future, a movement creating opportunities for Hawaii’s next generation by ending the workforce housing shortage. He lives in Haiku with his wife and four children.
When you want to decrease the size to 1,200 to 2,000 square feet,
itâs way too small for build for a growing family to build their dream home
on. Youâll have cottages with possible renters in them who donât listen to rules of
apartment living, have parties at all hours of the night, do drugs as well as
sell drugs, hear mopeds going in and out of the properties, etc. We should keep
single family living in Honolulu for single families, so we have peace and quiet for those who want
to live in single family homes. Perhaps the neighbor island might want
them but here in Honolulu, when we are finished working in town, we want to go
home to have peace and quiet and enjoy our families and not deal with stress from others living an arm's length away from our windows. So can you please explain to me why you think your idea is a
good one in passing these bills and can you have an architect draw a block of
these 1,200 /2,000 square feet lots and another block next to it so we can see
of how the two neighborhoods would look like in comparison and letâs see what
the pros and cons are between them. My name is Wilfred Motosue at 808-351-1553.
Perhaps we can talk face to face one day soon.
wymotosue·
10 months ago
Hi Sterling and Kealii,Iâve heard that you are for these bills. I am not for
these bills, so Iâd like to hear why this bill is good. Iâve lived in the
Kaimuki area all my life. I am a realtor, small developer for 40+ years
so Iâve built several small projects of 2 to 3 duplexes in the McCully,
Makiki/Ala Moana and Kapahulu area, a single-family home, subdivisions
etc. Iâve just completed and sold a 13-lot subdivision in Manoa.
I am 75 years old. As I drive around all these neighborhoods, I
really love how we homeowners have built their homes having side, back and front
yards, garages sometimes enclosed, grown trees and grass in their yards.
They look balanced, nice, and serene. I feel we should keep the size of
our lots in Honolulu this way, so we have space in our properties for our
families to enjoy every day. 5,000 square feet is not big but just right for a family to build their dream home and start raising their children in their new home.
wymotosue·
10 months ago
So allow investors to buy properties to put multiple homes now? That seems like a sure-fire way to increase the prices even further.
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.