Neal Milner: A (Possibly) Momentous Pronouncement By My 3-Year-Old Granddaughter
What to make of a little girl telling her dad she is “Jewisher” than he is, eight years later?
By Neal Milner
October 12, 2023 · 6 min read
About the Author
What to make of a little girl telling her dad she is “Jewisher” than he is, eight years later?
Sometimes, a moment in time is truly momentous. It has life-changing consequences lasting forever. Like the moment a spark ignited the Lahaina fire.
Religions stress those big, profound, life-changing moments: visions, conversion, redemption and renewal. Seeing the light, falling into darkness.
Even fire 鈥 the Burning Bush, the gates of hell.
And of course, miracles, the hand of God.
Hundreds of Lahaina residents believe that divine intervention kept sacred sites from being destroyed. Whether you believe that or not, it鈥檚 a common, powerful story.
I recently had a religious moment in time. It was not momentous at all, even though people with strong religious beliefs and others for that matter would love that moment and expect transforming consequences.
And yet in a way I still don鈥檛 understand there was something mysteriously miraculous about it, just not the kind you鈥檇 expect. Not a spiritual awakening, rather a puzzle about an earlier moment involving a chatty 3-year-old and her dad.
A little less than a month ago, my wife, Joy, and I boarded an Amtrak train taking us cross-country from Milwaukee to Portland, Oregon, where we would spend a couple of days with our children.
We left Milwaukee on Sept. 23. The date is important because Yom Kippur began at sundown the next day while we were on the train somewhere in North Dakota.
Yom Kippur is one of the Jewish High Holy Days. Beginning at sundown, observant Jews fast for 24 hours and spend many of those hours at synagogues praying.
You don鈥檛 need to know more than that to know Joy and I were not observing. We could have fasted on the train but did not. We should have spent many hours in a synagogue instead of a berth on the Empire Builder.
This was not our first fastless Yom Kippur. We had begun to travel on the Holidays and had stopped going to religious services.
We weren鈥檛 rebelling or resisting. Nothing dramatic had happened, no lapse, crisis or open rejection, not even a deviation. More like a haphazard wandering away, a drift rather than a march.
My son and granddaughter Viv were still at Yom Kippur services when we arrived at their Portland home. (My daughter-in-law was in Europe.)
For the first nine years of Viv鈥檚 life, they had lived in a Brooklyn neighborhood where you could fall out your door and land in a Jewish place of worship, but they had not gotten involved until they moved to Portland. This was Viv鈥檚 first Yom Kippur service, her first full-on service of any kind really.
鈥淕randpa,鈥 she said. 鈥淲e鈥檙e going to go back for the closing service. Come with us.鈥
Really? What a moment! Of course, I said yes.
Now, let鈥檚 stop right here and return to moments in time. It鈥檚 easy to imagine 鈥 probably some of you have fantasized this already 鈥 that this grandpa-granddaughter thing becomes a momentous moment in time.
Being with his beloved granddaughter who鈥檚 beginning the arc toward observant Judaism inspires grandpa to find the path again as he shares his knowledge about ancient rituals. A long-distance grandfather bonding through an ancient ritual with the grandchild he too seldom sees. Spiritual awakening and reawakening. It makes you swell with pride, 鈥渒vell鈥 in Yiddish.
There is so much Jewish lore in that scenario. In fact, so much lore among all sorts of families regardless of religion. Ohana, kupuna, keiki. Sharing mana鈥檕, passing it on.
Sweet story, but it didn鈥檛 happen.
The service was fine. I sang and prayed. The music was memorable, as in good memories, but it didn鈥檛 tap into anything deeper, no yearning to return. Nice to be back, thank you and goodbye.
Viv sat between her father and me for a while, then moved to be closer to the front. She was interested and never once complained about being bored, which she鈥檚 never reluctant to do if she feels that way any time, anywhere. She was curious, but science-project curious, not spirit-curious.
Afterward, she and I did not talk about that final hour. It never came up again.
But then I step back and think about it in the context of a much earlier event in Viv鈥檚 life, when there was an out-of-the-blue moment that was more mysterious, spiritual, eerie and just maybe momentous.
One day, when Viv was no older than 3, she said to her dad, 鈥淵ou鈥檙e Jewish, but I鈥檓 Jewisher.鈥
No one has any idea where this came from. Judaism was not a regular conversation and not something a 3-year-old who鈥檚 busy playing with her little stethoscope and tiny orthopedic hammer would bother with.
So, where did Viv鈥檚 statement come from? The easiest answer is, 鈥淲ho the heck knows? Kids say the darnedest things.鈥 That鈥檚 a cop-out.
A more professional explanation would be that kids learn through observation. True, but observation of what, exactly?
Maybe what 3-year-old Vivienne said was historical memory, somehow the voices of her ancestors moving from generation to generation in order to speak to her.
How, though? Historical memory is not about genetics. It鈥檚 about culture and folklore. It鈥檚 spiritual, not empirical.
Or maybe, as those believers in Lahaina might see it, it鈥檚 the hand of God starting her on a spiritual journey before she even knew what that is.
Maybe what she said at 3 was a divination that turns out to be a momentous moment in time for her.
Maybe it will start a fire but in a good way.
And maybe not. Who knows?
Yet those words to her dad that she said over eight years ago still intrigue me, still make me wonder.
Do I believe in miracles? I鈥檓 not the best person to ask. I ate blueberry cheesecake in a train rolling through the prairie on Yom Kippur.
But miracles are things that can鈥檛 be explained, and I definitely believe there are plenty of those.
Is Vivienne miraculous? Oh please. That鈥檚 grandpa brag talk.
Is she part of an inexplicable process that鈥檚 so much like religious mysticism?
Could be.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Ben Lowenthal: My Hope for Hawaii's New Supreme Court Justices
By Ben Lowenthal · October 13, 2023 · 6 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Neal Milner is a former political science professor at the University of Hawai驶i where he taught for 40 years. He is a political analyst for KITV and is a regular contributor to Hawaii Public Radio's His most recent book is Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Latest Comments (0)
Aloha Kumu Milner, thank you for sharing of the deep pause for reflection, the ancestral memory that is passed down to our keiki, to your mo'opuna in Viv. I found myself saying the exact same thing, to that effect, seeing my own two keiki echo the same sentiments of your Viv. My first born is named Kekauonohi, after her descendant Kupuna, a grandchild of Kamehameha I via Peleuli (w), Kahoanokukina'u (k), the first child of "Paiea" and Kahakuhaakoi (w). It is no coincidence Kekauonohi was awarded the second-largest allotments of land in the Great Mahele of 1848, making her after the King the largest landholder. Your picture above showed the Waine'e Tomb (now Waiola) where our Royal Maui Lineages are rested; Kekauonohi, Keopuolanl, Nahienaena, Liliha, Ulumaheihei (Hoapili Kane), Kaheiheimalie (Hoapili Wahine), Kaahumanu, Kaumualii. We invoke Moku'ula, Mokuhinia, Mo'o Wahine Kihawahine. Your Viv is invoking her affinity in being Jewish, more Jewish. Almost 50 years to the day of the Yom Kippur War, Viv's expression of faith, proclamation of connectivity, and pronounced pride in and of her kupuna ancestral memory, their continuity is made prescient and profound to PAPA. Rafah X
Manuel.Kuloloia · 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing this sweetness during these troubled times. Much love and happiness to you and your family.
Sad_Twin_Voter · 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing a very moving vignette of your family. Me thinks young Vivienne possesses much of her grandfather's gifts of superior intellect, blessed with a deep sense of humanity: a true mensch.
cavan8 · 1 year ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.