Hawaii Has A Long History Of High School Football Violence
The recent decision to cancel a Waianae-Castle match over safety concerns is just the latest chapter in a saga that goes back at least 60 years.
In her five years driving students to and from football matches, Thelma 鈥淢omi鈥 Kaneakua had seen her fair share of flying rocks and violent behavior. But the Kaiser-Farrington game at Aloha Stadium was different.
The first thing she saw was a flying bottle. Then she heard another bus driver yelling “fight.” She told the students on her bus to hide their heads and tried to reverse the bus, but it was blocked by an angry crowd. The next thing she knew, a teenager yelling 鈥淔arrington is No. 1鈥 had smashed the driver鈥檚 side window of the bus with a large piece of wood, fracturing her shoulder.
鈥淲e鈥檝e been stoned before but this was the worst stoning we鈥檇 ever had,鈥 Kaneakua told the Honolulu Star-Bulletin.
The 1977 riot at Aloha Stadium lasted 20 minutes. When it was over, eight students, two bus drivers and a parent were in the hospital. One of the teens — a horn player in the Kaiser band — needed surgery for a skull fracture.
The incident may have been the most violent high school football fight in Hawaii history, but it was not the first and definitely not the last.
The decision by school leaders last week to cancel a Waianae-Castle football game over safety concerns caused a great deal of consternation on social media, including an often-voiced worry that teens today are somehow lacking in the discipline of previous generations.
But Hawaii鈥檚 newspaper archives show the state has a long history of grappling with school violence, including violence centered around football rivalries.
Past incidents haven鈥檛 been confined to any one community or school. Kamehameha Schools, Kaiser, Castle and Waianae have all had their share of unsavory incidents in the past.
It took decades and a wide range of tactics by school leaders to get to the point where safety problems at games are a rarity rather than a norm.
Students Expect Routine Violence
The rock-throwing after games seems to have started in the 1960s. Or maybe it was sooner. Public school officials seemed hesitant to publicize the violence between fans of rival football teams, so many of the incidents didn鈥檛 make the news, a reader of the Honolulu Advertiser complained in a 1969 letter to the editor.
In 1967, the athletic director at Waianae High School a recent game at Kahuku was a tie. Everyone was satisfied and there wasn’t a single fight, he said.
“It used to be that every time we played at Kahuku, they threw rocks at our bus afterward. And then when Kahuku played here, they got rocks thrown at them,” he said.
The worst, he said, was when the team played at Waialua. “They have this overhead walkway just when you get to town. They stand up there, and man, they drop boulders on your bus when you go underneath.”
In 1968, a Campbell student was injured by a rock thrown at a bus after a Campbell-Radford game and suffered a permanent eye injury.
By 1969, teens hurling rocks at buses after high school football matches was so routine that players were advised to keep their helmets on and crouch below the window on the ride home from the games.
In 1975, the owner of a private bus company contracted by the school district, said football-goers Some 20 windows had been broken the previous year.
鈥淚s prep violence on the rise here?鈥 the Star-Bulletin asked that year, after a game between Kalaheo High and Leilehua in Wahiawa. Members of the band were getting ready to board the bus when a large can was hurled through the air, breaking a window and sending shards of glass into the hair of a school chaperone carrying a baby in her arms.
No one saw who threw the can 鈥渟o all the police could do was escort us off the grounds,鈥 the bus driver said.
Addressing The Problem
School violence — not just at football games but on campuses generally — became a focal point of public attention in 1975 after a 14-year-old student was killed in a fight at Waipahu Intermediate.
As pressure mounted to address fights and vandalism at games and on campuses generally, state education leaders came up with a bevy of proposals.
. Another suggestion — one of many in a package of proposals in 1975 aimed at reducing school violence — was to reduce the size of schools. Larger schools made more sense economically, but smaller schools seemed 鈥渓ess prone to violence,鈥 the head of the state Commission on Children and Youth said.
Other suggestions included special training for students, security patrols and a cultural studies program that would run from kindergarten all the way through high school to 鈥渇oster respect between students and reduce racial incidents.鈥
Just a year later, after religious leaders in the islands protested any plans to bring 鈥渟ecular mind disciplines鈥 into public schools, the Honolulu Advertiser wrote.
After the 1977 riot at Aloha Stadium, education officials increased security patrols. State lawmakers also convened multiple committees and commissioned studies to look at the cause of crime on campuses.
By 1978, every public school in the state was required to have a plan that addressed safety, security and campus beautification. The Department of Education also contracted with a private security firm to provide night patrols for 42 schools and “security counselors” for part-time work at a dozen schools deemed high-risk. They also trained nearly 200 safety and security aids and created a Civil Defense school surveillance program on Oahu where volunteers checked on schools at night.
Violence at athletic matches wasn’t always confined to public schools, though. In 1982, a fight between players on the field at a St. Louis and Kamehameha championship match “triggered a near riot” with at least four individual fights breaking out at Aloha Stadium at the same time.
“At least a dozen fans also came on the field, some of them throwing blows, before coaches and security people finally brought the fight under control,” the Star-Bulletin wrote.
For a few years there seemed to be a lull in news reports about violence at high school athletic meets. But in the early 1980s, a spate of rock attacks resumed.
In 1985, a student from the Castle football team was taken to the ER and treated for glass in both eyes after the bus he was riding was struck by nearly a dozen rocks after a game against Farrington. That same year, three Waianae High students were injured by rock attacks in Nanakuli on their way home from a game at Aloha Stadium. A similar attack was launched in Nanakuli at a bus carrying Kailua High School’s team — even though the team was escorted by three police cars.
After the 1985 incidents in Nanakuli, the state school superintendent called for the Nanakuli football team to forfeit its games for the rest of the season and for the team to have to play all its games the following year during daylight hours.
That seemed to mark the start of harsher sanctions on teams from schools where students were identified as the rock-throwers. In 1987, the Oahu Interscholastic Athletic Association ruled that after students were caught throwing stones at Pearl City High School buses.
Soon after, news reports about bus stonings slowed. So significant was the halt in behavior that in 1993 after a “hail of rocks” hit Kuhuku buses, the Honolulu Advertiser wrote an editorial calling for such incidents to be urgently addressed — before the hard work of educators and principals to address the behavior was undone.
When in 2012 after a rock was thrown through their bus window, it was a rare event — and a far cry from where things were in 1982, when a Honolulu Star-Bulletin headline proclaimed: “No Solution Seen in Attacks on Buses.”
“Ironically, football is the sport that brings in the money to run the other sports at the schools,” the paper wrote. “It’s also the sport that apparently arouses the high emotions as it’s the only one for which the schools hire police escorts for the buses.”
Civil Beat’s education reporting is supported by a grant from Chamberlin Family Philanthropy.
