Ben Lowenthal grew up on Maui. He earned his undergraduate degree studying journalism at San Francisco State University and his law degree at the University of Kansas. He is a deputy public defender practicing criminal defense in trial and appellate courts. He also runs . The author's opinions are his own and don't necessarily reflect those of Civil Beat.
An online spreadsheet quickly became a reference document for the community after the Lahaina fires.
The numbers are easy to find now.
Last week, it was reported that at least 66 people were still missing, and that an additional 80 people were also unaccounted for, the Maui Police Department said.
Right now, 63 of the 115 confirmed victims have been identified and the grim work of contacting families continues.
But data with this level of detail was in short supply in the days following the fires of Aug. 8, and in the absence of official information, the community quickly mobilized to share what they knew.
Like many people on Maui, I first learned about what happened informally. For me, it was a text message on Tuesday night. I had a hard time comprehending the words “Lahaina literally burning down.” I immediately turned to social media, and sure enough posts, pictures, and comments were all about the fires.
I stayed up late watching the news, checking in with others in group chats and messaging apps, and doomscrolling on Facebook. No information was coming out of the west side. Power was down. Cellphones didn鈥檛 work.
The next morning, what happened in Lahaina still didn鈥檛 sink in. The courthouse was open in Wailuku. I had hearings scheduled. People had gathered outside the courtroom for a jury trial. Then again by text message, I saw pictures of Front Street.
It was shocking.
The fires dominated my social media feed. Every post and picture, when it wasn鈥檛 about a fire, was a call for help from someone desperate for information. People were trying to find each other and were using any way they could.
The online pleas were everywhere:
鈥淲e haven鈥檛 heard from Mike Misaka since the fires broke out, If anyone has any information please reach out to us. Mike loved going to the pool (Lahaina Aquatic Center) all the time and he might be somewhere in the vicinity of there.鈥
鈥淟ooking for Linda Vaikeli From Lahaina Surf . . . Baker St.鈥
These pleas are accompanied by pictures of happier times at weddings, beaches, and gatherings. There was no official word on anything or anyone. No one knew where to go or how to find the thousands of people living on the west side.
Punctuating those photos of the missing were pictures of the sign-in sheets at shelters posted as early as the night of the fires. Everyone was doing what they could. A Haiku artist living in Minneapolis was motivated to post pictures of the lists.
I zoomed in on those pictures to look for people. I know I wasn鈥檛 alone because eventually, someone took the names from the lists and started a spreadsheet on a shared Google doc.
It has evolved into what became the .
At first the sheer number of names was overwhelming. It gave a sense of how massive this had become. But when I began going through it, I started recognizing names. I saw a friend from my local soccer league. I checked for my cousin鈥檚 family. I searched for clients 鈥 especially those living outside or with limited means of communication and transportation.
Over a month later, it remains a remarkable document.
It鈥檚 proof of a community 鈥 both online and on island 鈥 responding to an urgent and pressing crisis.
It is like a telephone switchboard meant to connect people and nothing more. And while the information is sparse, for friends, neighbors, and loved ones, it鈥檚 precious.
Many people on the list have been 鈥渇ound鈥 and are marked off in green. Sometimes that鈥檚 all it says.
The missing, or 鈥渘ot located,鈥 remain in red. Carlos Tobias 鈥淟ast seen in WAHIKULI. He wanted to wait for his wife because she was still at work.鈥 Danilo and Conchita Sagudang, not located, 鈥渆vacuated to Maui Prep, but not sure where after that.鈥 Alfie Rawlings, not located, 鈥渓ast seen at Hale Mahaolu Elua assistant living units.鈥
Some have MPD/FBI case numbers next to their names.
A better system has emerged now. County and State officials have released and urge the public to assist them in finding people. But in those early days of this massive disaster, it was all we had to go on.
And it has worked. The people locator lets everyone know who鈥檚 missing and who was found. Before official tallies, reports, and numbers, it was the only thing that family, friends, and loved ones wanted to know.
Now as the shock continues to wear off on this island, the spreadsheet continues while questions that still require an answer stack up.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Ben Lowenthal grew up on Maui. He earned his undergraduate degree studying journalism at San Francisco State University and his law degree at the University of Kansas. He is a deputy public defender practicing criminal defense in trial and appellate courts. He also runs . The author's opinions are his own and don't necessarily reflect those of Civil Beat.
This is a welcome positive story about how social media can be used for good. While this was happening, others in our community took to the internet to spread bizarre fire conspiracy theories thereby generating unwelcome and heightened fear, distrust and division among us. For example, immediately post fire a prominent West Maui real estate agent took to social media to post conspiracy theory videos on YouTube, apparently drawing the attention of conspiracy theory spreader extraordinaire, Alex Jones of InfoWars, who then hosted this fellow on his 8/29/23 podcast. During the show (available on line) the two of them forcefully suggested the fire was started by a Direct Energy Beam Weapon from a base on Maui or Kauai; saying the "the enemy" (Antifa, leftist environmentalist arsonists and other dark forces) were behind the disaster; and that FEMA, the government, Blackstone and banks are working together to rid Lahaina of land owners in a blatant land grab. Social media can be used for good, but it is also a ready source of misinformation deployed by bad actors for nefarious purposes intent on sowing distrust among.
Wiliwiliwarrior·
1 year ago
The spreadsheet is amazing. Is this something that CERT can use in their trainings?
Fruitfarmer·
1 year ago
They need to keep this document active. The official numbers are questionable to say the least.
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.