Danny De Gracia: An Open Letter To President Biden On How Federal Aid Can Help Maui
The US military has substantial resources that could support supply and reconstruction efforts.
August 14, 2023 · 6 min read
About the Author
Danny de Gracia is a resident of Waipahu, a political scientist and an ordained minister. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views. You can reach him by email at dgracia@civilbeat.org or follow him on Twitter at .
The US military has substantial resources that could support supply and reconstruction efforts.
The loss of human life and the destruction of so many homes and businesses in the wake of the Maui fires has gripped the hearts of observers the world over. While disastrous times like these cast a shadow over our existence, one also cannot help but be inspired by the outpouring of support and the willingness and initiative of the federal government to do whatever it takes to help the people of Maui.
I found particularly reassuring the swift response by President Joe Biden to this tragedy, in which federal funding will now be available for 鈥渢emporary housing and home repairs, low-cost loans to cover uninsured property losses, and other programs to help individuals and business owners recover from the effects of the disaster.鈥
This not only puts us on track to quickly rebuild once things are safe again, it also puts local hearts at ease that those who survived the fires won鈥檛 have to be impoverished in the process of getting their homes and businesses back.
Over and above this, the president also gave Hawaii his assurance that military resources would be made available in the short term, along with anything else that is requested or required for ongoing disaster management.
And this is where I feel an outside voice is necessary, because when it comes to federal assistance, the division of intervention between local, state, and national government is a matter of 鈥測ou have not, because you ask not.鈥 So I would like to use this column as an opportunity to write an open letter to President Biden, in ways that they can use their resources to help our Aloha State.
Dear Mr. President: Thank you for stepping up to help our people and our local elected leaders in this difficult time for all of us.
We appreciate your leadership and your compassion and are comforted by the fact that what makes America so strong is that in times of crisis, we always set aside our differences and come together to help those in need and to protect those who are powerless to help themselves.
I have the highest level of confidence in both your leadership and the leadership of my local government. However, it is understandable that at this time, some opportunities for assistance might be overlooked or not thought of, due to the overwhelming burdens that are being carried right now.
Here’s a list of things that would really help Hawaii, and the people of Maui, and I hope you will consider them.
Please send a hospital ship like the USNS Mercy or USNS Comfort to anchor in Hawaii. A long precedent exists in which the U.S. Navy often sends hospital ships to help project immediate medical capabilities to places with no health infrastructure or limited means to care for a mass casualty event.
After the terrorist attack on New York City on September 11, 2001, a hospital ship was sent to help give New York added healthcare capacity so the local systems would not be overwhelmed. The same happened during the coronavirus pandemic.
Please send a hospital ship to Hawaii to provide free health services for evacuees needing specialized care, particularly those needing kidney dialysis treatment.
Please arrange military passenger aircraft, civilian aircraft chartered by the federal government, and free travel vouchers with major commercial airlines so that Maui residents can fly to safe neighboring islands such as Oahu, or, allow Maui residents to fly to the mainland if they have family or caregivers willing to assist them.
This will be the most humane way to help survivors and their families. Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam has many C-17 aircraft that can be used for quick ferry missions, deliveries of supplies, and transport of Air Force emergency surgical teams if needed.
Please send an E-4B Airborne Command Post aircraft to Hawaii for use as an additional temporary joint command and communications hub for state, local, and federal authorities. Previously called the 鈥淜nee Cap鈥 plane during the Cold War (NEACP; National Emergency Airborne Command Post) the E-4B also can be parked on a runway and used as a field operations center. This highly modern aircraft is like a portable headquarters, and it could be safely parked in Maui to help with operations.
Mr. President, to avoid scarcity as a result of displaced evacuees and limited food supply on Oahu, please create a voucher system for evacuees to make use of pop-up federal commissaries and pharmacies providing goods, food, and medicines shipped from the mainland. This will ensure everyone is fed, clothed, and able to remain healthy without fear of local scarcity of supply or worry about how to pay for these needs after losing so much in the fires.
Please personally visit Maui and give your political weight behind reconstruction.
Mr. President, the most powerful thing you could do for us is to visit along with Vice President Kamala Harris, to personally embrace some of the disaster victims, to see firsthand the devastation, and to rally bipartisan congressional support for funding swift reconstruction.
If we become lax in this matter, the world will soon forget us and Maui could easily slip into a 30-year slump of economic stagnation. We need to have leadership that is committed, alert, and motivated to see us through this time.
As the son of a retired Air Force colonel who helped in the evacuation and resettlement of American citizens following the 1991 eruption of Mount Pinatubo in the Philippines, I鈥檝e seen what a competent disaster response looks like, and right now, there are elements of this Maui crisis management that frankly disturb me.
Mr. President, please help us get through this challenging time with efficiency and decisive action.
Correction: A previous photo caption incorrectly identified SBA Administrator Isabella Guzman as Deanne Criswell, the FEMA Administrator. It has been updated.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Hawaii Governor Seeks Moratorium On Property Sales In Lahaina
By Kim Gamel · August 14, 2023 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Danny de Gracia is a resident of Waipahu, a political scientist and an ordained minister. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views. You can reach him by email at dgracia@civilbeat.org or follow him on Twitter at .
Latest Comments (0)
Hospital ship- Good idea.Air transport- There's plenty of commercial inventory available; don't need a military passenger airlift capacity added. Vouchers are a good idea.E-4s? Not the same comms. spectrum; the civil services will be restored quite quickly; give it a few days. There are already mobile Wi-Fi & cell service nodes being used, and the networks are being restored.Power Generation via mobile generators- Already happening.Food and water provision- Only thing holding it up is "last mile", and those who do not want to come to where the supplies are being handed out. There's plenty of food on Maui, and the money is being passed out to supply and/or purchase it.POTUS has heard and is providing PLENTY of assets and resources, via USC Titles 10 and 32 assigned forces to JTF-50.Was self rescue and sufficiency required for a time? Yes. Comes w/ the territory; a remote island that's lucky to be in one of the 50 United States.I was in Subic Bay in 1991; the Lahaina catastrophe, while unbearable for many, pales in scope and scale to post-Pinatubo eruption operations and/or the Humanitarian and Disaster Response (HADR) missions performed globally.
Shoeter · 1 year ago
I've never understood why we need so much military here (or many other places, for that matter). Here's an opportunity for them to show us they're not only in the destruction & pollution business, but can help clean up, rebuild, reestablish damaged infrastructure... But, from what I can gather, there's too much bureaucracy, too many different agencies, too many channels to go thru to get people help... at least that's what the talking heads will say as they stand around pointing at each other. So, really, what is the point of all this?? If the US insists on maintaining a HUGE presence here, please- show the people they are actually on our side- and not just here to blow stuff up, take us space, and pollute our environment. If they can't, I say get out of the way because the local people are ready to do it themselves.
CSH · 1 year ago
The Posse Comitatus act prevents the Military to execute the laws, and prevents them from participating in civilian law enforcement endeavors. There is disagreement though in whether it allows them to be served as advisors or in a disaster relief capacity. I would think because we have a State National Defense office, and a state national guard. We have a coast guard and we have various national and state agencies that they would probably stand down unless ordered by the commander and chief, and Biden would probably wait and see how the State is responding.
TheMotherShip · 1 year ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.