Neal Milner: Enough Talk Already. Try Riding The Honolulu Rail In Silence
You can鈥檛 avoid rail talk by running away. Your only choice is to escape rail by embracing it.
By Neal Milner
July 6, 2023 · 6 min read
About the Author
You can鈥檛 avoid rail talk by running away. Your only choice is to escape rail by embracing it.
When it comes to Honolulu rail, cost overruns create verbiage overruns.
We need to liberate ourselves from all this rail talk. Enough already.
Rail talk threatens to be part of you for the rest of your life, like the still-throbbing toe you broke playing shirts versus skins basketball in 1979 or the bachelor brother who moved in 鈥渇or just a couple of weeks.鈥
Rail verbiage is more than just annoying. It鈥檚 misleading. Too much little picture, too little big picture. Lots of details, too little context. Words matter, but they also confuse.
To liberate yourself from rail talk, you need to free yourself from rail. But to liberate ourselves from rail, you need to ride rail. But in a special way and for specific reasons.
But I鈥檓 getting ahead of myself.
Background: The Rail Chase
Projections, rejections, dejections and objections. Change orders and court orders. Eminent domain and eminent people complaining that rail will be too far from or too close to their own domain.
It would fill a stadium if we had one. It would fill our landfill if that wasn鈥檛 filled already.
Foreground: Rail Today, Or At Least Last Week
Last week was the train鈥檚 grand opening. The keynote speech should have been themed along the lines of lyrics from the John Prine and Iris DeMent song 鈥:鈥
“In spite of ourselves
We’ll end up a-sittin’ on a rainbow
Against all odds
Honey, we’re the big door prize.鈥
We pulled it off in spite of ourselves. That鈥檚 real for sure. It鈥檚 accurate and to the point about the ups as well as the downs. Proud yet humble.
Best of all, though, the verse is short. Less than 20 words. Bim bam boom!
Instead, the public was treated to celebratory, half-time-pep-talk, bump-smoothing mush. Forget your troubles, come on get happy.
And all of a sudden, the thousands of people who thought that puppy would never leave its Waipahu kennel are all happy and surprised.
In spite of ourselves.
Fighting Back: The Strategy
So, if you are so sick and tired of rail talk, why should you deal with this by riding the thing?
Because you can鈥檛 escape. You are not a celebrity. Celebrities escape the clamor in their lives by going off social media. Bad Bunny is off Instagram.
You have no social media presence to go off of. You鈥檙e still using AOL.com.
Harrison Ford has an even better strategy. Go somewhere else. Ford owns a Wyoming ranch where he can get away from Indiana Jones and concentrate on punchin鈥 cattle and taking potions and lotions that miraculously preserve his rugged handsomeness.
And owning a ranch. Good luck when you can鈥檛 even afford a condo.
Riding the train quietly with no purpose and no concern for all the Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation verbiage you鈥檝e had to listen to for over a decade is your own wind-breaking protest against all the pro and con rail windbags you鈥檝e endured.
So, you can鈥檛 avoid rail talk by running away. Your only choice is to escape rail by embracing it. Make rail your own personal space.
Ride it but ride it alone. Spur of the moment. For no reason, no objective in mind.
Maybe one time, maybe more. Who cares? You shouldn鈥檛.
As The Buddha would say, live in the Skyline moment.
Do nothing. Talk to no one. No 鈥渉ow do you like the ride?鈥 For you it鈥檚 not really about the ride.
You are not the public. You are you.
Use your heart and head to create solitude. Solitary refinement, like fishing in darkness or bowling alone. It鈥檚 why a mother鈥檚 best vacation is staying home when the husband and kids go visit grandma and grandpa. 鈥淚鈥檒l miss you all. Stay as long as you like.鈥
How seldom you get to be in your own world! Rail talk is about everyone鈥檚 world lumped together, as in 鈥渢he public鈥 and 鈥渞idership projections.鈥
A Solitary Ride
Large numbers of people moving efficiently from place to place, getting there because they have to be there. They are on herd time. You are on me time.
Your everyday life is so much about places to be and people to see. Responsibilities, schedules, side jobs, coaching. 鈥 Foodland, Zippys, Longs.鈥
A solitary, unplanned rail ride is a well-earned oasis from rationality and routine. It鈥檚 that Snickers bar that out of nowhere you drop into your family shopping cart and eat in the parking lot before you get home.
It鈥檚 also a way to rage against the machine.
In anthropology there鈥檚 a story about a peasant turning his back and passing gas as a royal procession goes by. The peasant is too powerless to confront the king directly but wants to show some kind of protest.
Small-scale resistance, but resistance, nonetheless.
Riding the train quietly with no purpose and no concern for all the verbiage you鈥檝e had to listen to for over a decade is your own wind-breaking protest against all the pro and con rail windbags you鈥檝e endured.
Your un-rail rail ride is a way to peasant-like vent your rage against the machine: the political machine, the rail car machinery sitting idle all those years in their Waipahu quarters like long-term felons at the jail up the highway and the machinations of the planners, futurists, politicians and critics about pros and cons and long-term impacts.
Is this solitary but not lonely ride a temporary relief? Sure is, partner, but life is temporary reliefs. The solitary rail ride may not be a gift horse, but at least it鈥檚 not manure. You can鈥檛 make the world go away, but you can give it a kick in the pants for a while.
Advice to Harrison Ford: If it turns out that there will be yet another “Indiana Jones” movie, prepare by stunt-driving Dillingham Boulevard.
To get to a business near the Oahu Community Correctional Center a few weeks ago, I maneuvered through orange cone mazes that seemed like they were created by the same process that your server uses to create random passwords. Then I made an illegal turn past a stumpy, rusted temporary stanchion with a 鈥渘o left turn鈥 sign; parked illicitly in a wholesale grocery lot and walked a block dangerously close to moving cars to get to my destination, which was open though you would never know it unless you used a drone.
I just added to rail talk, didn鈥檛 I? Sorry.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Rail Contractor Sues HART Over Construction Delays
By Kevin Dayton · July 6, 2023 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Neal Milner is a former political science professor at the University of Hawai驶i where he taught for 40 years. He is a political analyst for KITV and is a regular contributor to Hawaii Public Radio's His most recent book is Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Latest Comments (0)
I golfed in Kapolei the other day and wondered, maybe I could take the rail next time and save gas? Well, if it actually went anywhere and I could park for free it might work. Maybe when it gets into Kaka'ako, it could be an alternative, but then there would also be an uber, or bus ride, if there is one, to get to the course. And this is what makes rail challenging, the transfers, or additional cost and steps to get to your ultimate destination and that would be 2 ways.Unless, you are an avid bus rider and only going to a specific one point destination, rail is pretty limited in the sense that Honolulu is not dense enough, yet (although it seems like it sometimes). We are no where near as compacted as Manhattan, or even San Francisco and locals do not like to walk, unless you are a senior and schedule early morning walks around the park. That said, I would expect rail numbers to be 30% of whatever HART predicts just because that was based on nothing but trying to justify its existence.
wailani1961 · 1 year ago
I road the rail, it would have been more pleasant if some of the people standing had used a deordorizer....however it was free at the time, so I guess that unpleasantness should have been expected....I've heard the ridership has declined since the grand opening, and that might be enough incentive to give it a second chance..
Triway1993 · 1 year ago
Well the number of people riding went down 95% (18,000 down to 1,200) on the first day it was not free. I don't know how you put a happy face on that.
DPHI · 1 year ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.