How Building More Backyard Homes And In-Law Suites Can Help Alleviate The Housing聽Crisis
Solutions will require rethinking existing policies and re-imagining what housing development and neighborhood cohesion looks like.
Solutions will require rethinking existing policies and re-imagining what housing development and neighborhood cohesion looks like.
To many people, the image of a nuclear family in a stand-alone house with a green lawn and white picket fence still represents a fulfillment of the American dream.
However, this ideal is relatively new within a broader history of housing and development in the U.S. It鈥檚 also a goal that has become .
, we explore how cities change over time, and how certain building trends become commonplace through cultural, political, technological and economic shifts.
Over the past century, the U.S. has lost a rich variety of living options because of the homogenization of zoning policies that prioritize single-family housing, as well as developers鈥 desire to have inexpensive and easily replicated building plans.
These development prescriptions are so pervasive that it is now illegal to build anything other than a single-family house in American cities. the supply of affordable housing, leading to higher costs, displacement and segregation.
Enter The ADU
Diverse patterns of living arrangements across families, communities and plots of land in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
To accommodate these living situations, a range of housing types emerged: multifamily apartment complexes, housing cooperatives, and duplexes and triplexes.
There were also accessory dwelling units, which are sometimes called 鈥済ranny flats,鈥 鈥渂ackyard homes,鈥 鈥渋n-law suites鈥 or 鈥渂ackyard cottages.鈥
These terms all refer to essentially the same thing: an additional unit of housing on a single lot, typically smaller in square footage than the main residence. They include full amenities 鈥 a kitchen and a bathroom, along with a separate entry from the primary dwelling. ADUs can either be attached to or detached from an existing house and can either be built from the ground up or be converted from existing spaces, like garages, basements or attics.
You may have heard of minimalist living trends such as and , but the ADU was the original compact housing.
While ADUs are not new, many Americans are unfamiliar with them. A recent found that 71% of homeowners were unfamiliar with the concept, though 32% expressed interest in having one on their property once they learned about it.
Addressing The 鈥楳issing Middle鈥
More diverse living arrangements are both desirable and necessary.
Recent trends 鈥 and , along with 鈥 all demand housing types that are not readily available in a market .
We believe ADUs 鈥 with their social, economic and environmental benefits 鈥 should become a more common housing option.
ADUs contribute to sustainability goals primarily because they encourage density. Rather than clearing another lot in a sprawling suburb for a new single-family home, the ADU stealthily adds density to existing neighborhoods, which allows them to tap into the existing infrastructure grid. They can also lead to fewer emissions by encouraging shorter commutes.
Because ADUs are smaller, they also require fewer building materials to construct and less energy to heat; they can be passively cooled and need less electricity. Together, these result in reduced energy costs for the building. Additionally, , which further reduces construction time, can sidestep regulatory burdens, such as site inspections, and lead to lower costs and waste.
ADUs are also nimble. Twentieth-century forms of development often took a scorched-earth approach to redevelopment by 鈥 often communities of color 鈥 to build entirely new districts through urban renewal programs.
ADUs do not disrupt local communities. Because they don鈥檛 require buying up more land, they help add to the density, introducing new people from different walks of life. As neighborhood populations grow, they become more attractive to small businesses. Coffee shops, restaurants and grocery stores are more likely to flourish with more residents in a given area.
ADUs can also fill the gap of much-needed 鈥溾 housing. Many new neighborhood developments are marketed as 鈥渓uxury鈥 and try to take advantage of hot markets by maximizing price points. Affordable housing is typically developed by government housing authorities and nonprofit developers who attempt to meet the pressing housing needs at the lower end of the economic spectrum.
Alternatively, housing that caters to middle-income people is typically nonsubsidized through traditional government funding mechanisms but fills a need that many for-profit developers can鈥檛 meet. These are usually smaller homes that attempt to appeal to a variety of . Many ADUs could fall into that category.
Finally, at the scale of the household, there are numerous benefits to ADUs.
Going back to its moniker as a 鈥済ranny flat,鈥 ADUs offer the opportunity for intergenerational living. They are typically a single story, which makes it easier for older family members to age in place. But they also provide space and privacy for younger people who may not be able to afford a larger single-family home.
Some ADUs . By adding units to the existing rental market, they can stanch . They can also provide passive income for homeowners who need help paying off their mortgage.
California Leads The Way
To be sure, . It often appears from local residents who fear that there won鈥檛 be enough parking spaces to accommodate new neighbors and that adding more dwellings to their neighborhoods could decrease property values.
Similarly, bureaucratic hurdles can sometimes discourage homeowners who might otherwise be interested in . Sometimes six or seven separate permits are required, significantly delaying construction.
Los Angeles has had a unique approach to encourage ADUs. The city recently launched its , which offers homeowners and developers the option to select from 20 preapproved ADU models for construction. Plans range from a studio structure of less than 400 square feet to a 1,200-square-foot house with three bedrooms.
Since construction or conversion is still relatively expensive and out of reach for many homeowners, the state of California also offers homeowners a $40,000 subsidy to encourage the construction of ADUs to make them more affordable. Meanwhile, CityLAB, a university-affiliated research center at UCLA, for homeowners looking to build one of these small homes. The guidebook provides a step-by-step process to walk people through information needed to submit an application to the city and find lenders, designers and contractors.
California鈥檚 various initiatives have largely been successful. ADU permits increased from 9,000 in 2018 to 12,392 in 2020, . Seeing the success of ADU policies in cities like Los Angeles and , is testing an ADU pilot project in a handful of neighborhoods. is also currently advancing legislation to reverse policies that forbid ADUs.
As the country grapples with alleviating its housing crisis, solutions will require rethinking existing policies and re-imagining what housing development and neighborhood cohesion looks like. ADUs can be one of those solutions.
This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Support Independent, Unbiased News
Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.