Robert Lee is a 2022 fellow of the Clean Energy Leadership Institute in the Bay Area cohort. He recently joined Stow Energy (a spinoff of Otherlab) to build thermal storage technology for home heating, cooling and hot water. Lee previously worked for Apple and is a graduate of Punahou School in Honolulu.
It honestly surprised me when my dad had a smart electric meter installed on his house in Nuuanu, as he鈥檚 never considered himself to be an early tech adopter. But as of 2021, only 31% of Hawaii Electric鈥檚 residential electric meters on Oahu are using smart meter technology.
Across the United States, 70% of all electric meters are designated as AMI, or smart meters that support 鈥渁dvanced metering infrastructure.鈥 Comparing this to electric providers in Hawaii, the Kauai Island Utility Cooperative is above average at over 95% advanced metering infrastructure adoption, but their smaller customer pool is ahead of the renewables game as a special case.
But total statewide advanced metering infrastructure only totals 41%. Smart meters are therefore a minority in the islands, making up less than two-thirds the national average.
Closing the smart meter gap is a critical part of modernizing Hawaii鈥檚 electrical grid. In the past, and have dampened the demand for more installations. But recent and have raised awareness about measuring electricity usage carefully, and the state must do everything it can to make energy leaner and greener to meet its goals for renewable energy.
Hawaii needs to start installing smart meters faster than ever 鈥 and customers need to know how to benefit from them.
Over the past decade, California and Hawaii have seen an incredible rise in solar power capacity. When the sun is up, customers who own solar panels don鈥檛 need to draw energy from the grid, causing a drop in demand for grid resources.
But once sunset arrives, demand on the grid spikes up until the day is finally over.
If you use your imagination, the mid-day demand sag looks like a duck鈥檚 belly, and the spike at sunset is like a duck鈥檚 head 鈥 so the total phenomenon is commonly known as the 聽 (Hawaiian Electric previously chose to call it the 鈥 a missed opportunity to choose a native species instead.)
Utilities can use the fine-grained energy usage data from smart meters to balance the supply and demand forces that make up the duck curve, and to forecast where the curve will be going. Without smart meters providing this data in real time, costly errors can happen when supply and demand don鈥檛 line up. For example, occur when the grid can鈥檛 provide enough energy to meet demand at its peak.
On the other hand, it鈥檚 possible to have too little demand for an oversupply of solar energy mid-day, in which case the excess energy must be wasted in a process called . Therefore, the utility is motivated to somehow shift energy demand away from peak hours, ideally into the off-peak mid-day period to take advantage of abundant solar energy.
This is why Hawaiian Electric would be motivated to have more of its customers, including my dad, have smart meters installed at no charge. Customers have ways to benefit from having smart meters as well 鈥 but at least in Hawaiian Electric鈥檚 case, they鈥檝e hardly taken advantage of them.
Where I live in California, nearly every home has a smart meter, and we use them every day to determine how much we pay for electricity under . Instead of paying for electricity at a flat rate per kilowatt-hour, we鈥檙e charged more for using power during peak hours () and less at any other hour.
On the website of my utility provider 鈥 PG&E, or Pacific Gas and Electric 鈥 they also have a feature called that lets me download my own smart meter data, which I can use to understand when my house uses the most power so I can figure out how to lower my bill for next month.
Back in Hawaii, Hawaiian Electric customers with smart meters can opt into and Green Button downloads too, but according to their , only a tiny fraction of customers are using these features out of the existing minority of AMI users.
To try these features out, I asked my dad to log in to Hawaiian Electric鈥檚 and download his Green Button data. Once we got his data, we found out something was using up several kilowatt-hours at the same time every afternoon. After seeing the problem, we figured out he had a bad timer set up on his solar water heater, causing it to start heating up water right as the sun was going down.
Without having the smart meter data, we wouldn鈥檛 have found the issue, but if he never checked the data and blindly moved to a TOU plan his bill would have increased significantly. As more customers receive smart meters, they should be encouraged to engage with their data as a low-cost way of auditing their energy efficiency, and consider trying out one of Hawaiian Electric鈥檚 TOU billing plans.
After learning more about why he got a smart meter and what it can do, my dad appreciated having a new tool to check on his electric usage and find ways to save money. But I鈥檓 not sure when my other friends and relatives back at home will be getting their own smart meters to play with.
From my perspective living with smart meters on the mainland every day, it鈥檚 more important than ever for locals to know the role smart meters play to help the electric company manage the supply and demand, especially as Hawaii decommissions and moves towards 100% renewable energy.
Locals need smart meters to help guide their individual decisions on power consumption. Using better data to move power demand off-peak will improve grid resilience while saving everyone money.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many
topics of
community interest. It鈥檚 kind of
a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or
interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800
words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia
formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org. The opinions and
information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
Robert Lee is a 2022 fellow of the Clean Energy Leadership Institute in the Bay Area cohort. He recently joined Stow Energy (a spinoff of Otherlab) to build thermal storage technology for home heating, cooling and hot water. Lee previously worked for Apple and is a graduate of Punahou School in Honolulu.
Unless the data is important to you, keep your old meters. HECO has already conceded that customers with older meters are likely paying lower rates (or less than their fair share), because the meters slow down over time. Time of Use rates are mostly useless and HECO should stop patting itself on the back about it. For the vast majority of electrical users like me with normal jobs and lives, the ToU rate schedule would significantly raise my bill. Maybe it makes sense if I work nights or have a vacant home most of the year.
rs84·
2 years ago
Don芒聙聶t agree w/need for smart meters. Peak demand in early evening is a no brainer: families are home芒聙聰 dinners, baths, homework, electronics. How does HECO change that? What they can do is shut off power at their discretion, when in the middle of cooking dinner. Used to be public service announcements. What happened to those? HECO could give energy saving tips on how to conserve energy or spread out use time to lessen grid peak demand. One tip is to install a switch instead of a timer to control water heater on times manually to fine tune with needs.
kateinhi·
2 years ago
"In a landmark order that could set the tone for electricity rates across the country, the state Public Utilities Commission has ordered Hawaiian Electric to transform its existing power rate structure into one that better acknowledges the growing use of renewable energy" Star AdvertiserLooks like there's a chance that HECO will be forced to change the way it formulates its billing due to the increasing alternative power generation sources.
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.