Catherine Toth Fox: Why Do We Feel Compelled To Get A New Phone Every Year?
Apple has been introducing new products and upgrades in special events for more than a decade. But this time around, it seemed only true Apple nerds seemed to care.
Born and raised on Oahu, Catherine Toth Fox is an editor, writer, children鈥檚 book author, blogger and former journalism instructor. She is currently the editor at large for Hawaii Magazine and lives in Honolulu with her husband, son and two dogs. You can follow her on Instagram @catherinetothfox. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Did you watch it?
I didn鈥檛. Nor did anyone I know.
Apple has been turning press release material about new products and upgrades into special events broadcast around the world for more than a decade 鈥 and the buzz has been legit. Consumers and critics chatter online about these new products for weeks leading up to the events, speculating what the tech titan has been secretly designing on its Cupertino campus.
But this time around, when Apple announced upgrades and product redesigns at its 鈥淔ar Out鈥 event on Wednesday, only true Apple nerds seemed to care. Even Eve Jobs, the daughter of former Apple CEO Steve Jobs, mocked the event on her Instagram story, showing a meme of a man holding up a plaid shirt identical to the one he鈥檚 wearing with the caption, 鈥淢e upgrading from iPhone 13 to iPhone 14 after Apple鈥檚 announcement today.鈥
Another great line from the comments of an online blog about it: 鈥(Far Out) is a reference to the price of the new iPhone. Far out of reach of mere mortals.鈥
I feel the same way most years, when Apple reveals its newest lineup of smartphones, laptops and other gadgets that don鈥檛 seem very different from what I dropped an entire paycheck on the year before.
In a word: underwhelmed.
And yet, here I am, reading about the new, that I don鈥檛 need, a camera with a faster aperture that I don鈥檛 need, and a crash detection feature that I don鈥檛 need. And I鈥檓 thinking, 鈥淢aybe?鈥
Apple is the master of getting into my head like this. I already own two MacBook Pros, a MacBook Air from 2011 (that still works), a 27-inch iMac that鈥檚 somewhere in the back of my closet, Apple TV, an Apple Watch, an iPhone 13, a pair of Air Pods, a classic iPod that might be worth more than it cost when I bought it and an iShuffle that won鈥檛 even charge. Now I鈥檓 almost convinced that this new iPhone could save my life. (I mean, what鈥檚 $1,099 when you鈥檙e talking about your life?)
And there it is: The idea that I may need an overpriced upgrade to a phone that I already own, that works just fine.
This is how on the planet by market cap at nearly $2.5 trillion as of September.
It has created what鈥檚 referred to as an ecosystem. Apple has carefully and systematically designed a user and lifestyle experience 鈥 also called a 鈥渨alled garden鈥 鈥 starting with the launch of the first iPhone in 2007. It鈥檚 a system-wide integration where having more Apple products results in a better user experience.
It鈥檚 not something the company talks about 鈥 and definitely not something it outright sells 鈥 but it鈥檚 why we plunk down hundreds of dollars on products we probably don鈥檛 need but feel like we can鈥檛 live without. Like using your Apple Watch to unlock your Mac or responding to iMessages from your laptop (which is, to me, the absolute greatest thing in the world).
But in this day, where people are struggling with health care costs, housing costs, unemployment, the rising price of everything from used cars to steaks, combined with a sensitivity toward frivolous spending and over-consumption and its impact on the environment, it seems irresponsible to drop $1,000 on a new phone when I already have a working one.
And it also seems irresponsible for a company worth trillions to continue to push out high-priced products and entice consumers to buy buy buy when it鈥檚 really not necessary.
So why do I feel the urge to rush down to my nearest Apple Store and buy a purple iPhone with a new feature called 鈥渄ynamic island鈥 that I still don鈥檛 quite understand? Or new Air Pods that have a button at the bottom of the case that alerts you to the location of your missing earbuds? Or an Apple Watch with a compass or one that can predict my ovulation?
Because, as journalist J.B. MacKinnon , 鈥淭he Day the World Stops Shopping: How Consumerism Saves the Environment and Ourselves,鈥 we can鈥檛 stop shopping 鈥 and yet we must.
鈥淚t is another of consumerism鈥檚 ironies that, although it functions like a mental trap, we often think of it as an escape.鈥 A very misguided and expensive mistake 鈥 and one that I won鈥檛 make today.
I鈥檓 holding out for the iPhone 15.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Born and raised on Oahu, Catherine Toth Fox is an editor, writer, children鈥檚 book author, blogger and former journalism instructor. She is currently the editor at large for Hawaii Magazine and lives in Honolulu with her husband, son and two dogs. You can follow her on Instagram @catherinetothfox. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
I had a Nokia 3010. It wouldn't die. I took it out into the backyard and beat it with a hammer. Later that night, it came back in the house and started ringing.
CatManapua·
2 years ago
Apple is doing what every successful company does to survive-advertise and promote its products. I don芒聙聶t feel we should shame Apple for doing what companies do to grow. If they stayed stagnant, they wouldn芒聙聶t grow and they may fold. They芒聙聶re a hugely successful company and good for them! And I love it when they come out with new technology. It芒聙聶s fun and I like to take advantage of it. Their products have enhanced my life. We芒聙聶re lucky to have these tech designers who come up with all this great and innovative stuff. Like one of the commenters said, Apple isn芒聙聶t forcing us to renew our phones every year. They芒聙聶re just advertising their products because that芒聙聶s what companies do to thrive. Apple also helps keep the stock market afloat which benefits people like me who have their 401K in the stock market. I need to have successful companies in order to have a comfortable retirement. And we can recycle our products responsibly.
MauiAloha·
2 years ago
Use it up, wear it out, make it do, or do without.
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.