Lee Cataluna is a columnist for Civil Beat. You can reach her by email at lcataluna@civilbeat.org
A year and a half ago, we waited anxiously every day for the updated Covid-19 statistics from the state and gasped if the case count rose above 30.
Now, the daily number is hovering between 600 to 800 new cases on most days and it鈥檚 like, 鈥淥h well. At least it鈥檚 not over 1,000.鈥
A strange numbness has crept in when it comes to numbers. It鈥檚 the kind of apathy or stupor born of frustration and helplessness. If you feel you can鈥檛 fix something, you learn to live with it broken. After a while, you figure out how to not let bad things bother you, and you go about your business. It鈥檚 a way to cope.
But the Covid numbers in our state should bother us.
As of the start of this week, the death toll in Hawaii from the coronavirus pandemic is 626 people.
That鈥檚 more than the entire senior class at Farrington High School.
That鈥檚 more than four full Hawaiian Airlines interisland flights.
That鈥檚 more than a third of the entire Honolulu Police Department.
Imagine the entire bottom floor of the Hawaii Theatre, both the orchestra seats and the parterre, with every seat taken and a few dozen people standing in the back. That many people have died.
And still we鈥檙e arguing about vaccines and social distancing and restrictions on gatherings like it鈥檚 all theoretical and not actual humans, our neighbors and friends and fellow citizens, dying.
Maybe we鈥檇 notice those 626 deaths en masse, but somehow, the singularity of each death, the isolated nature of an agonizing decline in a hospital ICU, the disconnect so many people have between the reality of the pandemic and the lies and conspiracy theories they鈥檝e swallowed have blunted the impact of all those people, our people, our neighbors, who have died in this outbreak.
We should be all-in on prevention. We should be demanding 鈥淣OT ONE MORE!鈥 We should be unified in 鈥渆nough is enough.鈥
Tragically, we are not.
In contrast, there are the freak occurrences that snap everybody to attention.
Remember being afraid of rat lung worm on raw vegetables?聽 Yeah, nobody called that a hoax or a conspiracy. You know how many people in Hawaii died from rat lung worm? Two. Eighty-two people got sick, some of them very sick, some with lasting disabilities, but nobody got all huffy and insisted that washing your lettuce was an infringement of personal rights.
that caused liver failure in 72 people in Hawaii? Two people died. The Food and Drug Administration and the Hawaii Department of Health moved quickly to shut that down. Compare that to the use of a livestock de-wormer being ingested off-label to 鈥渢reat鈥 Covid.
鈥淚f people would only have the opportunity to walk around the ICU hallways and see what鈥檚 going on.” 鈥 Dr. Larry Antonucci of Florida
Messages from the state and the feds are worded as advisories and warnings, not bans. The other difference is that nobody insisted that they knew better than the FDA and vowed to keep taking the diet supplement because it鈥檚 their body and their choice on how to hurt it.
The Covid numbers have become as mundane as the . Nearly every time someone dies in a car crash, the local news media dutifully reports the tally of traffic fatalities that occurred in Hawaii so far that year and compares that number to the year prior. Does that make anyone drive more carefully? Rhetorical question. We all know the answer.
Here is another set of numbers that doesn鈥檛 seem to have impact:
There were 45 new COVID cases on Kauai on Monday. Remember when Kauai鈥檚 number was proudly holding at a steady 0? Kauai was a role model of how to protect a small town, but the compounded pressure of business interests and demands of personal freedom made all the safeguards fall away and, apparently, increased residents鈥 tolerance of knowing the virus was in the community.
Dr. Larry Antonucci, CEO of a hospital in Fort Myers, Florida, offered a great observation聽about this number-blindness over the weekend. Antonucci鈥檚 hospital has seen a dozen Covid patient deaths a day in that one facility and he expects that number to grow in coming weeks. 聽鈥淚f people would only have the opportunity to walk around the ICU hallways and see what鈥檚 going on and seeing the sickness and how young people are being struck down with this disease,” he said.
But all they see is numbers, not people.
That鈥檚 great big Florida. This is little Hawaii, where we still find two-degrees of separation between ourselves and total strangers (i.e. 鈥淵ou work with Larry? Larry is my cousin!鈥), where we have respect for our elders and treat other people鈥檚 kids like they鈥檙e our kuleana, too.
Or maybe Hawaii isn鈥檛 like that anymore. Maybe that鈥檚 a myth that this state has outgrown. Maybe we鈥檙e just like everywhere else, disconnected and disaffected, more interested in a fun fight or a bloody battle than notions of civic duty or world peace.
Let鈥檚 hope not. Covid has taken hundreds of Hawaii’s people and has left thousands more strangely, eerily, unconcerned.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
We grieve and mourn for the dead, then we move on.聽聽 That is how life is and should be.聽 It's not that we're
"unconcerned."聽 Whether it's
one or one thousand deaths, each is meaningful.聽 Although the coronavirus will be with us forever, one day, this pandemic
will end and life will go on...as it should.
Hoku·
3 years ago
The media needs to take responsibility for this dulling of the senses with their constant basketball score reporting of case numbers.聽 Being fed the same grinding news which has no depth to it.聽 What the media and medical community fail to provide are the details into cases and more importantly deaths.聽 How can the community digest and know what the risk factors are without knowing what "underlying circumstances" mean?聽 Only recently the news reported that out of Hawaii's 560 plus fatalities something like only 11 people did not have "underlying circumstances."聽 It would then be pertinent to provide a list of high risk conditions so that risk group could take added precautions?聽 We can guess that obesity is a key risk factor, with that often comes diabetes and high blood pressure, smoking and others.聽 This is disease is not ebola deadly and it can be controlled if we have the pertinent information and take precautions.聽 聽
wailani1961·
3 years ago
"What, me worry about my societal responsibilities? Pfft. What about my individual rights?" Who prefers to have this virus continue to circulate indefinitely instead of acknowledging that it's a pandemic and doing what you can to lower the rates of illness and death?
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.