Denby Fawcett: Hawaii Tourism Needs To Become Smarter
October 20, 2020 · 8 min read
About the Author
Denby Fawcett is a longtime Hawaii television and newspaper journalist, who grew up in Honolulu. Her book, is available on Amazon. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views.
Hawaii welcomed more than 10,120 travelers Thursday at the launch of the state鈥檚 new program that allows visitors with negative tests for COVID-19 to skip quarantine.
Now that travel is slowly coming back, it is time for Hawaii to create a new tourism model for a changed world in travel that will benefit both tourists and the local community.
The in its says shutdowns around the world have prompted people to be more reflective about what they want in their lives, including what they expect now from travel. WTTC鈥檚 new study released last month is titled 鈥溾
鈥淔rom widespread unemployment and anti-racism movements to the restoration of natural habitats and the impact on ecosystems,” WTTC says, “the world has been re-invigorated to tackle social, environmental, and institutional sustainability.”
The heightened awareness is extending to tourism in the craving for safer travel and a need to do more than just seize entertainment opportunities when traveling, but also to be more respectful of the local environments and people.
Watching natural settings bounce back in the absence of people during lockdowns has made many people aware of how much damage has been done to places just by visiting them.
The WTTC report says there is a desire for greener tourism, ecotourism that鈥檚 also mindful of the needs of tourism workers in the community that鈥檚 visited.
Although it is cynical, there is truth in Machiavelli鈥檚 famous quote: 鈥淣ever waste the opportunity offered by a good crisis.鈥 The opportunity is here to change the way we do tourism.
Nobody is eager for a repeat of 2019, when a whopping 10.4 million visitors arrived in Hawaii, frustrating residents by commandeering their favorite beaches and hiking trails, crowding into beloved island eateries and disrupting quiet residential neighborhoods as they cavorted in illegal vacation rentals.
After the economic ravages of the pandemic, travel experts say the same annual influx of 10.4 million tourists will not reoccur for a long time, maybe never, if the state gets real about weaning itself from tourism as its main economic driver.
In the meantime, travel experts internationally as well as in Hawaii are looking at opportunities offered by the coronavirus crisis to remake the travel industry worldwide greener, cleaner, smarter and more responsive to social issues such as economic inequality and environmental degradation.
Longtime Hawaii travel expert Frank Haas is writing his own report to consider how to meet new travel expectations of visitors.
Haas is a former vice president for marketing for the Hawaii Tourism Authority and the co-author of the study 鈥.鈥
Here鈥檚 what travelers will be expecting in the next few years ahead, according to the WTTC report and Haas.
Flexibility And Safety
In the WTTC report, 70% of North American leisure travelers said they would book trips during the pandemic if they were assured there would be no penalty charges if they changed their plans.
Travelers will expect to be offered more flexibility in the uncertainty of the pandemic, a twilight period expected to extend for at least another year, maybe two years.
Almost 70% of the respondents said cleanliness was crucial to their comfort as they traveled.
Intense attention to health and germ avoidance is expected to continue even after a vaccine becomes widely available.
One thing that bodes well for Hawaii, according to the WTTC report, is travelers during the pandemic now want to go to places they already know.
鈥淭raveler preferential behavior has shifted toward the familiar, predictable and trusted, domestic and regional vacations and the outdoors.鈥
I take that to mean visitors returning to the islands now are here because they feel safe and know they can easily find their way around rather than venturing into more unfamiliar destinations in Europe and Asia.
Add to that the reality that U.S. residents with our country鈥檚 high infection rates are still prohibited from traveling to a long list of countries including Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the nations of the European Union and Japan.
The WTTC report says during the pandemic 鈥渢ransparent communication will be ever more important to travelers in spurring demand.鈥
It says, 鈥淓xtensive communication and the flow of accurate information between travelers and employees, businesses and suppliers and visitors and local communities will be a leading engine in the recovery of the sector.”
Communications And Technology
That鈥檚 where Hawaii is weak. Its communication during the pandemic to both travelers and local residents has been muddled and sometimes non-responsive.
In the days leading up to Thursday鈥檚 reopening, tourists and returning residents struggled with confusing information on where to get tested and the different testing requirements for the neighbor islands.
In a newspaper article, freelance writer Erick Bengel wrote about trying unsuccessfully for two days to reach someone by phone at the state鈥檚 Hawaii Safe Travels service desk 鈥 a desk that promised to return calls the next business day. Nobody ever called him back.
Haas and the WTTC report both emphasize the large role technology will play in the future in making visitors feel safe by offering them touchless travel among other conveniences.
Touchless travel means the use of smart phones to do functions normally required by person-to-person contact.
WTTC says during all the lockdowns, people all over the world became increasingly comfortable and dependent on the internet, learning to use new platforms on their cell phones and computers for many aspects of their lives.
Now they will expect to use technological applications as an important part of travel comfort and safety.
They are interested in contactless travel, to avoid infection, using their smart phones to check in at a hotel鈥檚 front desk, summon the elevator and to get into their hotel room without having to touch a key.
Phones are also now routinely used for touchless transactions including as airplane boarding passes and while shopping and in restaurants to read menus and pay for meals.
In the WTTC report, almost half (45%) of travelers said they are ready to move from paper passports to a digital identity.
鈥淭he pandemic has made contactless technology more important than ever,鈥 says Haas.
The changes were always on the horizon but the pandemic has accelerated their development and use.
WTTC鈥檚 researchers say smart technology in every aspect of tourism and travel will necessitate not only increased cyber security but also upgrading the skills of travel and tourism employees to become familiar with the new systems.
WTTC says 68% of the workforce globally will need retraining to keep up to speed with the changing technology.
In the report he is writing, Haas wonders if there should be a new 鈥渃hief technology officer鈥 at the Hawaii Tourism Authority or the state Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism to focus on the need.
He also sees this as a new opportunity in technology training for travel for the University of Hawaii.
The University of Central Florida is already offering a program of travel technology and analytics.
Haas says the UH could set up its own smart travel program and become a leader in helping other countries meet the new demands for technology applications in tourism.
Executives already helping Hawaii鈥檚 blue collar hotel workers increase their skills are concerned that the increasing use of technology in hotels may displace more workers than it advances.
鈥淚t is nice to talk about upgrading hotel workers鈥 technological skills but you can鈥檛 discuss that without talking about the jobs that are already becoming obsolete because of technology,鈥 said James Hardway.
Hardway is the executive director of the Hotel and Restaurant Employment Training Trust Fund, funded by Local 5, the hotel workers union, to teach workers new skills and enhance their existing skills.
In the future, technology will also help better manage and spread out crowds by helping visitors to make advanced reservations and pre-payments on-line for many popular attractions.
And future travelers are expected to be more willing to accept new requirements for reservations because they will help them maintain physical distancing.
They may not be able to go to an attraction exactly when they want but at least when they arrive they won鈥檛 be smashed up against other people.
And advanced reservations will give local residents a better chance to return to their their favorite places, those they’d started to avoid because of tourist mobs.
This may be overly optimistic but if done with a creative spirit, a new tourism plan to meet the challenges of the pandemic and beyond might make Hawaii better for tourists and residents alike.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Campaign Corner: Let's Respect The Electoral Process 鈥 And The Candidates Who Make It Work
By Tracy Ryan · October 20, 2020 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
天美视频 is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Denby Fawcett is a longtime Hawaii television and newspaper journalist, who grew up in Honolulu. Her book, is available on Amazon. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views.
Latest Comments (0)
Smarter tourism requires the impossible -- elected officials suddenly becoming smarter.
sleepingdog · 4 years ago
"Nobody is eager for a repeat of 2019, when a whopping 10.4 million visitors arrived in Hawaii, frustrating residents by commandeering their favorite beaches and hiking trails, crowding into beloved island eateries and disrupting quiet residential neighborhoods as they cavorted in illegal vacation rentals."I generally disagree with the author's politics, but I can understand the above sentiment.聽 Once my family did a 'staycation' on Maui and it was disgusting to see how the tourists (primarily from the mainland) left their garbage everywhere in the very nice hotel, sometimes mere feet from a trash can, and seemed to have so little regard for the fact that local people do actually also live in the area.So I think the general concept is a good one.聽 The hard part will be finding great people to develop and maintain such a system in a sustainable manner.聽聽Personally I also favor catering moreso, if possible, to the Japanese tourist market.聽聽
pueobeach · 4 years ago
Hawaii state government, and Technology, are not compatible. Technology has taken a backseat in our state government for years now. The money allocated towards upgrading its systems to help out the citizens of this state is pure ineptitude.You have to wonder why technology and communication have taken a back seat to corporate interest and big money.
Scotty_Poppins · 4 years ago
About IDEAS
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.