Editor's Note
This is article is part of Civil Beat’s investigative series “Black Market Babies.” Click here to read the other stories.
In 15 years, Meryann Lomae went from being an apparent victim in a shady Marshallese adoption to being convicted for committing adoption fraud herself.
In 2003, found Lomae living with other pregnant Marshallese women at an apartment complex in Red Hill. The women told the reporter that they had been recruited by a fixer in the Marshalls and given tickets to fly to Honolulu, where they would put up their newborns for adoption, despite a law in the island nation against soliciting.
The reporter did not quote Lomae, just mentioned she was there. But another Marshallese woman who鈥檇 been at the same apartment complex told the reporter she had no idea she was relinquishing her child for good and had lost contact with her after the adoption — a typical experience for the birth mothers.
Public records indicate the Lomae moved to Washington state sometime after the 2003 Baltimore Sun stories. In 2010 or so, she moved to Arkansas, home to the biggest Marshallese community in the United States and a hub of Marshallese adoptions.
In 2017, Arkansas attorney Vaughn Cordes contacted police to file a complaint about Lomae. Cordes said one of his facilitators, Justin Aine, had connected him with Lomae so that he could arrange an adoption for her unborn child.
Lomae signed an agreement to have her child adopted by a Kentucky couple, Cordes said, and accepted more than $13,000 for living expenses while she was pregnant.
Cordes and his associates had lost contact with Lomae when Cordes got a call from a worker at a local hospital. The worker also was trying to find the Marshallese woman. She told Cordes that Lomae had given birth a week or so before.
It turned out Lomae had started working with a different attorney who specializes in Marshall Islands adoptions, . Her child had been adopted by a different family.
Lomae pleaded guilty in September and was sentenced to 120 days in jail. She also must pay $28,521 in restitution.
Lomae is one of several Marshallese women convicted of adoption fraud in Arkansas. Some of those familiar with the prosecutions have questioned whether the birth mothers are being forced to take all the blame while the role of lawyers and recruiters goes unexamined.
Petersen and his paralegal, , were listed as prosecution witnesses. But because Lomae pleaded guilty before going to trial, their role in Lomae鈥檚 change of attorneys never came out in court.
Matthew Long, an attorney for Petersen, declined to comment on the Lomae case but said in general Petersen鈥檚 adoption cases are subject to extensive reviews and he has never been found to be out of compliance with the law.
Kevin Lammers is an Arkansas public defender who represents many Marshallese women in this circumstance. While not commenting specifically on the Lomae case, he said he believes in general that private attorneys and fixers may mislead birth mothers about the terms of their agreements 鈥 or what it means to take money from two different lawyers. He thinks in some cases, women are pressured to switch lawyers.
鈥淚 have suspicions about what’s going on,鈥 he said. 鈥淏ut until I can actually bring somebody into court that says that this was misrepresented to them鈥 my hands are tied.鈥
He鈥檚 always recommended his clients take a plea deal 鈥 despite crippling restitution payments.
鈥淭hese aren’t people who really have the means to be making these payments,鈥 he said. 鈥淏ut I know I can’t have my clients go to a trial where the perception is that this is a business for them in this community and face five to 20 years in Arkansas prison.鈥
GET IN-DEPTH REPORTING ON HAWAII鈥橲 BIGGEST ISSUES
Support Independent, Unbiased News
Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.
About the Authors
-
John Hill is the Investigations Editor at Civil Beat. You can reach him by email at jhill@civilbeat.org or follow him on Twitter at .
-
Emily Dugdale was an audio reporter and producer for Civil Beat and the podcast Offshore.