Aside from a medical disability and unreasonable time away from family, I left a Department of Education classroom after more than a decade of selfless service to our students, appalled that our national and state DOE has deserted our youth, inadvertently complying with an education system where standardized testing and funding fears have trumped the complex needs of our students.

Once dedicated and passionate, I reluctantly joined the ranks of disgruntled teachers purged after more than a decade of top-down, business model public education increasingly defined by testing and publishing companies.

鈥淣o Child Left Behind鈥 and 鈥淩ace to the Top鈥 will be remembered as 鈥渢he Iraq War of public education鈥 鈥 that is, an ideologically fabricated crisis to perpetuate federal intervention and privatize public education, while fostering a legacy of 鈥渃ollateral damage.鈥 Unaccountable corporations like Pearson are 鈥渢he Halliburtons of education,鈥 profiteering off taxpayers.

Whereas wars are created by politicians but paid for by soldiers and civilians, economic interests in education have enriched a few industries, creating casualties among students and teachers traumatized by 鈥渄rill & kill鈥 curriculum conformity and endless mandates by non-teachers. Who stands to profit more from computer-based testing than Bill Gates, a financial propagator of national Common Core standardization?

Headquarters for the Hawaii Department of Education. Civil Beat/2010

Our premature 鈥渕ission accomplished鈥 moment was when U.S. Education Secretary Ernie Duncan pronounced Hawaii 鈥渁 model for rest of the country鈥 鈥 while teachers and administrators were vehemently condemning the micromanaging and destruction of our schools. Granted, there is a need for some changes and accountability. But the scorched-earth policy of the so-called 鈥渞eform鈥 movement that labels entire complex school communities as 鈥渇ailing,鈥 thus warranting 鈥渢akeover鈥 by private contractors, is antithetical to the principle of local control of education and turns discontented education professionals into 鈥渋nsurgents.鈥

Hawaii’s Educator Effectiveness System for teacher evaluation was rolled out before it was operational, yet teachers were expected to agree to it by contract before they knew what they were voting for. Conscience led me to boycott it, as I didn’t want to compromise the education of my students through politically driven decrees created far from classrooms. While my administrators and students respected my civil disobedience reflected in otherwise high ratings, the system deemed me 鈥渕arginal鈥 for my noncompliance.

Contrarily, Hawaii鈥檚 DOE was praised by the national DOE for being compliant, compared to districts nationwide where teachers, parents, administrators and students have boycotted mass testing and other curricula directives. Last year鈥檚 EES results reveal the farther from the classroom, the rosier one鈥檚 ratings: While classroom teachers averaged 鈥減roficient,鈥 teachers working outside classrooms that averaged 鈥渉ighly effective,鈥 whereas DOE executives received generous pay raises and credit 鈥 all while entire schools condemned the improper and ineffective use of EES that piles on busy work for the caring, committed teachers and creates unnecessary divisions among staff.

Just as bad war policies of the past helped breed the current proliferation of terrorism, so, too, has a decade of mass testing instituted a culture where students, teachers, learning and entire schools have been reduced to dehumanizing scores. We treat children like stock market commodities: Numbers, without regard to any exploitation or ecocide behind those numbers.

Just as bad war policies helped breed the current proliferation of terrorism, so, too, has a decade of mass testing instituted a culture where students, teachers, learning and entire schools have been reduced to dehumanizing scores.

For students, this means learning has been replaced by mindless test prepping, stress-related illnesses, more cheating and general rebellion against a system that cares more about scores than student needs. When I asked a former 鈥渟tar student鈥 why she looked beyond exhausted, she replied, 鈥淚鈥檓 having to choose between sleeping, eating or AP homework.鈥 Why is it that those who can afford private schooling may receive an education based on cutting-edge, evidence-based learning, whereas public school students get standardized testing 鈥 something research has debunked as helpful for learning?

While education professionals advocate cultivating 鈥渢he whole child鈥 鈥 nurturing multiple intelligences to nurture well-rounded critical thinkers and creative problem-solvers who can process information and ethically capitalize individual strengths 鈥 our system has been reduced to economic prerogatives. While 鈥渃areer & college readiness鈥 is desirable, should that be education’s sole purpose? This narrow redefinition by chambers of commerce exalts data over wisdom, sapping relevancy, relationships and inspiration from schools.

Please don’t take my word for any of this. Engage any recent student or teacher on their experiences.

We need much more than air conditioners; public school students deserve an education of quality on par with private schools, as the health of any democracy necessitates a quality education system for all its citizens 鈥 not just those who can buy one.

Of course, this is where the military/education system analogy ends: There always seems to be money or deficit spending for wars, but rarely education. Our youth deserve better than 鈥淲hole Child Left Behind.鈥

Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many topics of community interest. It鈥檚 kind of a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800 words and we need a current photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org.聽The opinions and information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.

Support Independent, Unbiased News

Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.

 

About the Author