Todd Simmons: Carly Fiorina and the Race to a Government Shutdown
The former CEO’s false attack on Planned Parenthood, a breakout moment in the GOP debate, stoked an environment where a shutdown is all but certain.
In last week鈥檚 heavily watched Republican presidential debate (22.9 million viewers, making it the most-watched program in CNN history), few moments emerged from the three-hour talkfest as sharply as against Planned Parenthood.
鈥淎s regards Planned Parenthood, anyone who has watched this videotape, I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama to watch these tapes,鈥 said Fiorina, her theatrical delivery steeped in contempt. 鈥淲atch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.鈥
Trouble is, what she alleges is on the infamous videotape is not there, as highly regarded and and have reported in the days since the debate. Despite Politifact rating her claims 鈥渕ostly false鈥 and Planned Parenthood calling them Fiorina continues to , angrily claiming she鈥檚 seen the images and others haven鈥檛 bothered to watch the tapes.
But the veracity of Fiorina鈥檚 claims almost don鈥檛 matter, at this point. The controversial video, heavily edited by the that produced it, attempts to show Planned Parenthood involved in a discussion about for-profit organ procurement from aborted fetuses.聽As Civil Beat editorialized recently, it has become a potent symbol for the tea party crowd and those, such as Fiorina, who seek to exploit that demographic鈥檚 passion.
The idea that such a venomous rebuke of Planned Parenthood would come from a well-educated, professionally successful woman 鈥斅燾haracteristics of the organization鈥檚 typical core supporters 鈥 gives it even more political impact. One expects such vitriol from a Mike Huckabee, Bobby Jindal or Rick Santorum. But the Stanford-educated former CEO of Hewlett Packard?
Far from hurting her, Fiorina seems to have only been helped by her screed. A 聽conducted in the three days following the debate and released Sunday showed Fiorina鈥檚 support spiking to 15 percent, up from 3 percent just 1陆 weeks prior.
Two days after Fiorina鈥檚 comments, the U.S. House of Representatives passed a measure along party lines that would freeze all federal funding for Planned Parenthood. U.S. Reps. Tulsi Gabbard and Mark Takai were among 187 who wisely voted against the measure, but 241 members supported the bill, passing it with plenty of room to spare. And that was but one of several current pieces of legislation in the House and Senate, all aimed at stripping Planned Parenthood funds from the budget, further restricting abortion access, or both.
The political environment nurtured by Fiorina鈥檚 comments and related dynamics pushes the government ever closer to a shutdown, as there isn鈥檛 enough time to pass any of the 12 federal spending bills, and the 鈥溾 nature of the Planned Parenthood disagreement will make it highly difficult to pass a continuing resolution temporarily funding the government.
The shutdown would have immediate impacts for Hawaii and for the thousands of federal workers who live here. Honolulu is the economic engine that drives Hawaii, and our city is the second-most reliant in the country on federal paychecks.
Other impacts are less apparent, but still significant. Example: Because Hawaii鈥檚 colleges and universities serve significant numbers of military personnel and their dependents who use federal support to cover their tuition costs, they suffer significant disruption when those students unexpectedly decide to skip an academic term, unsure whether their tuition checks will arrive.
While the Senate is likely more able and than the House, that may be damning with faint praise, as it鈥檚 not yet known whether Majority Leader Mitch McConnell can keep the Senate in line. If he or House Speaker John Boehner seek to pass a continuing resolution without majority support from the majority party, they鈥檇 face vindictive anger from party colleagues, not to mention heavy-duty Democratic demands in exchange for the minority party’s help.
Along with Gabbard and Takai in the House, delegation colleagues Brian Schatz and Mazie Hirono are doing what they can in the Senate to keep the government open for business. But their efforts won鈥檛 be nearly enough to overcome elected extremists who are salivating over the chance to shut things down and who point to their party鈥檚 success in last year鈥檚 elections as proof that the 2013 shutdown didn鈥檛 cost them a thing.
It鈥檚 tough to argue with that logic. In 2o14, the GOP retook the Senate and gained 16 seats in the House, despite bearing most of the responsibility for that similarly contrived and wholly avoidable shutdown.
Whether voters will be as forgiving this time remains to be seen. The train officially runs off the tracks in eight days, with the fortunes of 300 million Americans in tow. Is there a leader or leadership group with the character, force of personality and knowledge of process to prevent that? Highly doubtful, but with the clock ticking, let鈥檚 hope someone surprises us.
GET IN-DEPTH REPORTING ON HAWAII鈥橲 BIGGEST ISSUES
Support Independent, Unbiased News
Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.