UH Regents Should Say No to Fossil Fuels
Divestment from fossil fuels will be an act of good stewardship and one small step toward a stable planet and a saner future.
The University of Hawaii proudly declares on its website that it is a 鈥渓and, sea and space grant institution,鈥 one of only a handful nationwide.聽UH holds as its motto Maluna a驶e o n膩 l膩hui a pau ke ola ke kanaka (above all nations is humanity).
With faith in that identity and that motto, , a campus and community coalition, looks to the Regents for leadership in divesting from fossil fuels. Divesting from fossil fuel companies weakens their social and political clout, including their efforts to fund climate change deniers. It also creates an environment for legislators to pass laws limiting the carbon pollution that is causing global warming.
聽鈥淣o/Minimal鈥 Cost to Divest
The due diligence has been done. The Regents鈥 own task group recommends beginning divestment of its $66 million endowment from fossil fuel companies. Its financial advisors have confirmed that there will be 鈥渘o/minimal increase鈥 in fees to do so.
Energy companies comprise 5 percent to 7 percent of UH鈥檚 portfolio. When divestment is complete, in three years, UH will have no more than 1 percent of its holdings in fossil fuels and, where feasible, will look to invest in alternative energy companies.
The separate UH Foundation endowment is worth $261.5 million. Less than 12 percent 鈥 under $32 million 鈥 is in “Natural Resources” and “Private Oil and Gas.” The endowment grew by more than that just in the past year.
The endowments wouldn’t be losing the money, of course 鈥 just reinvesting it elsewhere. Investing in renewable energy companies will be an investment in the solution instead of the problem.
Capital expenditures for fossil fuels are rising while production is falling; clean energy is doing exactly the opposite. Investors are leaving coal in droves, and even oil company stocks have not risen consistently in recent decades. They performed in the upper half of equity sectors in only half of the years between 1992-2012.
Rising CO2 and Stronger Hurricanes Are Reminders to Act Now
UH divesting from fossil fuels will add to the groundswell of what is now an international movement.
The goal is nothing less than the salvation of Earth as we know it. We need to preserve beaches, to prevent Category 5 hurricanes, to save the reefs and the enormous assortment of life that depends on them.
Typhoons like Haiyan that wreaked havoc and cost thousands of lives in the Philippines are a grim reminder of what climate change is doing to our planet and its people. Scientists considering a new Category 6 on the Saffir-Simpson hurricane scale, and the parts per million of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere recently passing the dreaded milestone of 400, should stiffen our resolve to divest.
Divestment Good for Financial Health
At least five respected financial organizations have analyzed divestment and found that it does not weaken portfolios, and sometimes strengthens them. There’s good reason to expect future fossil fuel value to drop, due to stranded assets as people finally scramble to avoid destroying their world.
The resulting Carbon Bubble has been estimated to be 20 times the size of the mortgage bubble. The bubble may have already begun to burst in the last weeks of 2014, when Chevron put its plans to drill for oil in the Arctic “on hold indefinitely,” citing “the level of economic uncertainty in the industry.”
In short, divesting now may well save money, while the costs of climate change are likely to be incalculable. In January, the Legislature began a discussion about state pension funds. Not acting now drives up the cost of responding to the damage of climate change later 鈥 and taxpayers bear the burden. Voters should be paying attention to how their legislators act 鈥 or fail to act 鈥 on this issue.
For now, the UH Regents have an opportunity to lead the way by voting to divest. Once before, people said divestment would not work. The goal was to end apartheid. The Regents of the University of California expended time and effort debating whether to divest. People said it was pointless, risky, against their fiduciary duty. In 1986, the UC Regents voted to divest $1.7 billion from companies doing business with South Africa. They joined institutions worldwide in ending an unjust, discriminatory system.
Fighting the Culture of Fossil Fuel Companies
The Regents of the University of Hawaii are poised to play a similar role in contributing to the end of another deeply harmful culture: the culture of fossil fuel companies and their pursuit of profit at all costs.
Divestment from companies doing business in South Africa in the 1980s proved to be eminently not pointless, not risky, and not against fiduciary duty.
Divestment from fossil fuels today will prove to be the same. It will be an act of good stewardship, entirely consistent with UH鈥檚 professed identity and one small step toward a stable planet and a saner future.
GET IN-DEPTH REPORTING ON HAWAII鈥橲 BIGGEST ISSUES
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many topics of community interest. It鈥檚 kind of a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800 words and we need a current photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org.聽The opinions and information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
Support Independent, Unbiased News
Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.
About the Authors
-
Joe Mobley Ph.D. is a professor in the School of Nursing at UH Manoa and former vice chancellor of academic affairs at UH West Oahu. His research area is the behavior of marine mammals, particularly humpback whales, which he has studied primarily in the Hawaiian Islands since 1980.
-
Doorae Shin is a community organizer and environmental advocate. She currently works as the Surfrider Foundation Oahu Chapter Coordinator and is the co-founder of the Good Food Movement. Shin previously served as the Plastic Free Hawaii program manager for Kokua Hawaii Foundation and the Student Sustainability Coordinator for the University of Hawaii Office of Sustainability.聽
-
Leilei Joy Shih is a PhD candidate in Oceanography at the University of Hawai鈥榠 at M膩noa and the Sustainability Representative on the UH Graduate Student Organization. She is the Conservation Chair and an Executive Committee member for Sierra Club O鈥榓hu, working on issues including clean energy, invasive species management, and smart growth.
-
Brodie Lockard founded 350Hawaii.org, the Hawaii chapter of 350.org, in 2014.聽It is devoted to fighting the climate crisis.