There was no Christian rock band jamming at the Capitol Tuesday morning. Nobody waving protest signs. No chants about 鈥渕arriage equality鈥 or prayers for 鈥渉omosexual sinners.鈥
Just a nice breeze, a couple pigeons and a few ladies wearing rainbow-colored lei. It was a far cry from the rallies in the rotunda and passionate testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee that consumed the Capitol Monday.
All the action on the second day of the special legislative session to pass a same-sex marriage bill was on the floor of the House chambers where the rift in the majority and minority caucuses widened for all the world to see. Or at least the dozen or so members of the public seated in the gallery.
The House Finance and Judiciary committees are set to hold a joint hearing on the gay marriage legislation, , Thursday morning. To up the odds of defeating it, House Republicans tried to pull Rep. Cynthia Thielen from the 13-member Judiciary Committee. She鈥檚 the lone Republican in the Legislature who supports gay marriage.
Rep. Bob McDermott, one of seven Republicans in the House, put forward four resolutions that attempted to dismantle committee makeups and change leadership coalitions.
Three were deferred until Wednesday, but Speaker Joe Souki entertained . Among its proposed changes was replacing Thielen with Richard Fale, who opposes gay marriage, on the Judiciary Committee and replacing Aaron Johanson with Gene Ward as minority leader.
The debate on the floor opened with McDermott nearly yelling at Souki, challenging the speaker鈥檚 authority and alienating his colleagues in the process. Tempers flared as the discussion ensued and Souki had to call for security at one point.
Hawaii Reps. Aaron Johanson, left, and Cynthia Thielen sit in House chambers, Oct. 29, 2013.
McDermott said the coalition Republicans formed with majority Democrats to give Souki the speakership last year is no longer working. He said there鈥檚 no transparency and the power structure should be changed to put new leaders in charge.
鈥淭his whole arrangement has destroyed the minority caucus,鈥 McDermott said, referring to himself as 鈥渢he most hated man鈥 in the minority caucus.
Ward didn鈥檛 even know his name was being put in for a leadership position. Using the speaker鈥檚 name as a verb, he told Johanson that he would not 鈥淪ouki him.鈥
鈥淵our caucus is divided. My caucus is divided. The people are divided,鈥 Ward said, but added that 鈥渓eadership is keeping unity.鈥
Ward went on to point out that Souki had replaced Rep. Rida Cabanilla, likely a 鈥渘o鈥 vote on gay marriage, with Rep. Dennis Coffman, a 鈥測es鈥 vote. (In a separate action, the House passed a resolution to with Cabanilla as majority floor leader.)
That was when Souki banged his gavel, telling Ward he was out of order and calling for the sergeant-at-arms. But the brief recess that followed apparently didn鈥檛 calm tempers.
McDermott called Johanson out for trying to 鈥渟ave his own hide鈥 and then it was Rep. Cindy Evans trying to bring the House back into order. She said the rules don鈥檛 allow reps to make comments like that about their colleagues.
Moments later, Rep. Chris Lee鈥檚 speech in opposition to the resolution was cut short by Ward interrupting him and accusing him of breaking the rules by referring to some of the House Republicans as the 鈥渆xtreme right.鈥
Republican Beth Fukumoto stood up and left the room.
鈥淢y decision to leave the floor today was in response to Representative McDermott鈥檚 insistence on destroying a legitimate strategy to restore balance in the public process and perpetuating politics as usual,鈥 she later said in a statement. 鈥淚 felt no need to be a part of the personal attacks or the purposeless and chaotic actions that do nothing to advance the cause of stopping the same-sex marriage bill or helping the Republican Caucus and the people we serve.”
Hawaii Reps. Jo Jordan, left, and Marcus Oshiro talk, Oct. 29, 2013.
McDermott鈥檚 resolution drew support from fellow Republican Richard Fale and Democrats Jo Jordan and Marcus Oshiro, a longtime supporter of the previous speaker, Rep. Calvin Say.
Eventually, the motion was defeated by voice vote. The resolution would also have broken up the bipartisan coalition by taking away the three vice chair seats Republicans were given for their support of Souki.
Johanson released a statement later explaining why he disagreed with his colleagues鈥 effort to reorganize.
鈥淭his counterproductive strategy sends the wrong and untrue message that when Republicans don鈥檛 get exactly what we want, we cannot work with people in good faith and in a constructive manner to achieve our objectives,鈥 he said.
鈥淩emoving Representative Thielen from the Judiciary Committee is not the only way to kill the bill.鈥
Fukumoto said she would support the idea of removing Thielen from the Judiciary Committee if the proper procedure was followed 鈥 an internal decision by the Minority Caucus in concurrence with House Rules.
鈥淭hus far in this special session, the deck has been entirely stacked against the opponents of same-sex marriage, and it was my hope that we could help restore balance to the committee and the public process,鈥 she said.
鈥淯nfortunately, Representative McDermott decided to make this a political move, personally attacking other members of the body without reason in an effort to make a point rather than a difference. I could not support his mission to cause chaos without any effective purpose in sight.鈥
Hawaii House Speaker Joe Souki, left, talks to Rep. Ken Ito, Oct. 29, 2013.
Thielen considers herself a 鈥渕ainstream Republican.鈥
鈥淚 believe some of these social conservatives have done more damage to our party than some of the Democrats have done,鈥 she said.
She recalled joining the GOP in the 1950s, a few decades after Republican President Teddy Roosevelt founded the National Park Service. And she fondly remembered Barry Goldwater supporting gays in the military in the 1970s.
鈥淚 support marriage equality,鈥 Thielen said. 鈥淚 may be the sole Republican in our minority caucus that does … but I can guarantee I鈥檓 not the sole Republican in our community who does.鈥
The Senate passed SB 1 on second reading Tuesday and is set to hear it Wednesday for a third and final reading before sending it over to the House for its consideration.
Huge crowds are expected again Thursday at the Capitol. While the bill is expected to clear the Senate by a wide margin, the votes in the House are a lot tighter and amendments will likely be introduced concerning religious exemptions.
Thousands of people have testified on the bill and the House has created a new system to improve efficiency. (Read about it .)
Civil Beat will continue its live blog throughout the week. You can follow online here and join the conversation as the issue continues to develop.
GET IN-DEPTH REPORTING ON HAWAII鈥橲 BIGGEST ISSUES
Support Independent, Unbiased News
Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.
About the Author
-
Nathan Eagle is a deputy editor for Civil Beat. You can reach him by email at neagle@civilbeat.org or follow him on Twitter at , Facebook and Instagram .