So if you haven鈥檛 already heard, the Governor has been launching pieces of an initiative to deal with homelessness in Hawaii. Any effort is commendable, but I find a problem with the current rhetoric surrounding his efforts. I鈥檝e often mentioned that dealing with homelessness will require dealing with it in very human terms and not through systems and bureaucratic thinking.

But so far his additional comments only foster the same inhuman, and ultimately unrealistic, perspectives that already exist. Worse, I think they inflame the idea in people鈥檚 minds that homeless people are completely opportunistic, and enjoy scavenging for food and shelter. Suddenly his recent words are casting me, and those like me, into a role as pariahs.

When he recently announced his 9 Point Plan there were several comments he made about regular citizens not feeding the homeless. Essentially he said that providing meals for homeless would encourage more people into the homeless population. As if people will see a homeless life as preferable because there鈥檚 free food involved.

To be honest I鈥檓 highly offended because I feel like I鈥檓 being treated like a pigeon in some eradication effort: 鈥淲atch out! If you feed them they鈥檒l band together and breed uncontrollably! And we all know how much a blight those flying rats are on our nice, cultured city!鈥 If it really worked that way this would have been my story arc:

鈥淚 can barely remember the day that I hatched, but I recall it was a sunny day as my moist eyes struggled to open in the new blaze of light. My folks took good care of me as a young squab: They chewed my food for me, and picked the mites off my little head. But the idyllic life came to an end and I was on my own. I was young and I was hungry.

At first I made some friends with another pigeon and a sketchy couple of sparrows. They taught me how to dumpster dive. It wasn鈥檛 glamorous once your feathers got all matted down with grease, but hey, those McDonald鈥檚 leftovers were heavenly. That was until we heard from a stumpy-footed dove that there was a place where we could get all the free food we wanted; a veritable Shangri-la in the middle of the park.

So we followed him to where these bipeds were sprinkling small specks of something all over the grass. I followed the other birds in, and before I knew it I was in the rhythm of the mob, pecking, cooing, and jostling with the different birds all around me. Within a few minutes we had devoured everything and there were no more specks to be found. The bipeds left and the different flocks disbanded, leaving a few insistent doves still searching the tufts of grass for any missed nuggets.

But guess what? The bipeds came back the next day. And the next, and just kept on coming. We settled into that part of the park and repeated this bacchanalian feast each day. It was sheer bliss and we had no more worries. So we caroused and for kicks we would park our rear ends over the power lines and relieve ourselves trying to make patterns on the metal boxes with wheels and any unsuspecting biped passing by. Life was good and there wasn鈥檛 anything that was going to make us quit.

Except maybe some lame Governor鈥檚 initiative…鈥

So yes, if the Governor is to be believed, this little fictitious tale is a rendering of how more people will end up un-homed or homeless. He even uses criminal language of 鈥渁iding and abetting鈥 for those well intentioned bipeds. And somehow he thinks this 9-point action plan would counter all this. Whoopee!

Well I鈥檝e thought about it a bit and I have 9 points below to offer up. If these were in the forefront of their minds while enacting any plan, I might have a measure of confidence in their quest to be helpful. In my simple opinion, a home is (not necessarily in order of importance):

  1. Sanctuary- a place of refuge and retreat
  2. Safety- a state of feeling secure and protected
  3. Boundary- something that buffers the outer world as well as the inner
  4. Memory- a place to store and build a life
  5. Nostalgia- a needing to return to a source, and the fulfillment of that need
  6. Dignity- an innate right as a human being, flawed or not
  7. Independence- a chance to be free within and amongst the rest of the world
  8. Control- the chance to decide whether the toilet seat stays up or goes down
  9. A state of mind- an inner recognition that can鈥檛 be simply enforced through dictate

I鈥檓 sure there can be many variations, but if the proposed council can somehow begin to address these effectively then I鈥檇 have reason to believe. And perhaps other un-homed might as well. And at the same time if the Governor, in his capacity for wisdom and compassion, could drop his rhetoric that places homeless amongst the lower ranks of 鈥渟cum and villainy鈥 (to quote Obi-wan Kenobi for a moment), then maybe he鈥檇 build trust among these constituents. I鈥檓 sure at least some of them vote.

In the meantime, we pigeons will do what we can to survive and hope for the best.


Previous posts in this series:

Support Independent, Unbiased News

Civil Beat is a nonprofit, reader-supported newsroom based in 贬补飞补颈驶颈. When you give, your donation is combined with gifts from thousands of your fellow readers, and together you help power the strongest team of investigative journalists in the state.

 

About the Author

  • Joe Bright
    Joe Bright is a graduate of Iolani School and went on to study art at The Cooper Union School of Art in New York City, and later Chinese medicine at The American College of Traditional Chinese Medicine in San Francisco. Joe currently runs a small acupuncture clinic, Kama鈥檃ina Acupuncture in Kapahulu as the first dedicated low-cost 鈥渃ommunity acupuncture鈥 clinic in Honolulu. Joe has a varied background that has included working as a bicycle mechanic, freelance artist, teaching calligraphy and Tai Chi, a nanny, and even a CEO of a small entrepreneurial company. He continues to create art, even having work recently appear at the Honolulu Academy of Arts as well the Bishop Museum. He also continues with entrepreneurial projects when possible and serves on the Board of Directors for a local Buddhist meditation organization, Vipassana Hawai鈥檌.